If you paired the watch to your iPhone and did not unpair the watch from the phone before returning it, then the watch is under Activation Lock to your Apple ID and is unusable by anyone else.
Remove Watch Activation Lock -
Go to icloud.com and login
Open Find iPhone.
In the All Devices pulldown menu select the Watch.
In the resulting sheet that appears to the right choose erase Apple Watch. Select Next until the device is erased.
Then Remove the watch from your Apple ID.
This should reset the watch to the factory settings.
M1 Mac mini, macOS 11.1; Watch, series 5 GPS/cellular, watchOS 7.3.3; iPad Pro 2nd Gen, iPadOS 14.4.2; iPad Air 2, iPadOS 14.4.2; iPhone 12 Pro, iOS 14.4.2; TV 4th Gen, tvOS 14.3 HomePods, audioOS 14.3 and Airport Express w/ Airplay 2