Replying to an email with "Hide My Email" address?

Here is my problem: I use "hide my email" to purchase something from Guitar Center....after which they sent adverts I do not want. In order to unsubscribe you must email a different G.C. address. In composing a new email it does not offer me the "hide my email" address as an option......So how do you populate a new email with the "hide my email" address you used when sending to a different initial address? Ugh! Dennis

Hi. I tried this but it did not work for me, or maybe my understanding is not correct. I received an email to my “Hide my email” I’d and as a test I replied to it but sent it to my partner to check if it works - My partner could see the real email address. Am confused how does the reply function works and how to reliably test it?

Thanks

I thought at first this didn't work either, but it does. I used a generated email to get some info. Looking at the email I received it shows To with the hide my email address, and it even generated an email for the sender. I tried to fwd the message to my work email and I could see my real email, which made me think it did not work. I then emailed the hide my email from my work and it looked like the other sender's email with my hide my address and an email generated for my work address. I responded to my work email test message and when I looked at the header received it was from the hide my email address. So my actual email was never compromised. It is just confusing because when you hit reply it shows you your actual email address.

In my test, this is not the case. When you reply the replyto header includes my real email address.

See also discussion at https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/hide-my-email-may-be-revealing-forwarding-email-address.2315844/

Is there a chance I'm doing something incorrectly?

Or does it only work with a full icloud.com email address?

How are you able to open the email on icloud.com? My inbox is empty (because I use gmail).

@MichelleT18

Thank you so so much!

As you can see below, Apple Support couldn’t even answer this simple question!!!! Claiming that I need help ‘using a fake IP’….I mean technically it’s a forwarding domain but when you work for apple, that’s not how you should explain or talk professionally as a support agent for Apple! I’m a loyal Apple Guru, I love ios15 and the new features & iCloud+ users ….we now get more bang for our buck, an apple understands how important identity fraud & data protection is…especially with the relay option as well….putting the end user first where we have more and more control of our data and the the impact toxic data has across the board, and while many different tech giants are moving in the same direction to ensure that the best standard practices are in enforced to ensure end users with trained support staff that can respond to simple queries with professionalism when need be……brand loyalty is everything in todays competing digital era.

Hopefully, this simple and correct answer is noticed and appreciated by others.

Warm regards,

S

Thanks for posting in the Apple Support Communities obscurD,

We understand you have questions about responding to email sent from an email address generated with Hide My Email, and linked to the communities from Learn more about Hide My Email and iCloud+.

When you respond, your personal email address will remain private. The new message will appear as if it was from the Hide My Email address.

You can find additional information, here: Create unique, random email addresses with Hide My Email and iCloud+

We hope this helps!

Hello,

when I try to reply (from my Google Suite Gmail) iCloud server will reply with error message:

550 5.7.1 Delivery not authorized

Hey! How about hiding your email right from the email app when creating a new email? How do you go about doing that? Say I want to email an online shop inquiring about their product but don't want to share my real email with them, does the iCloud+ help in that regard?

For example, my real email is 123@456.com but want to use an autogenerated email instead to send my inquiry, is that possible?

I just replied to an email from a vendor who used my "Hide" address in their email to me, my reply as I drafted it showed my real address, the "sent" copy of the email also shows my real address. So it looks like my real address is what will show at the vendor's end. Please advise.

THANK YOU AND GOD BLESS YOU OVANIN!!

that worked!!!!! I signed into iCloud, got to my email and boom! It showed the HIDDEN EMAIL I PICKED in the FROM FIELD! I wish Apple would have developed a way for the main email app to work but thank goodness there is at least A Way!!

Don't try to fwd it to another address. Have your wife email the HME address, and then respond from your email as you normally would. When she receives the reply your address will still be hidden.

I'm having the same issue. I sent an email to a "hide-my-email" address and tried replying to it. I also get the undeliverable message. Seems they didn't fully think this one through.

You’re right, you can see all the generated email *addresses* .. but not the emails that have been sent to these addresses.

The bug appears to be in the iCloud mail server backend.

@brianfromindialantic

Ditto. Many ISP’s and their ‘direct,’ or indirect’ affiliate mail filtering services are blocking iOS users with iCloud+ and it’s ‘hide my email’ service which isn’t a surprise to me or others.

We knew this day was coming anyway and Apple will find a workaround once their ‘Relay’ feature, currently in its Beta version, works and works well! …..

Can apple create something that will save ‘all’ their loyal users from having to purchase a separate yearly VPN/Encrypted network…time will tell.