Hello taylorgriggs1086,
Thanks for reaching out to Apple Support Communities. Upon review of your post, it seems that you want to know if you can still see a replay of your Apple Music history, without allowing the app to save that data. We can see why you’d want this clarified, so let us help from here! The short answer to your question is no. If there was no recorded data, there will be nothing to show. This helpful article was linked to your posting in case you have additional questions about how this works: Apple Music Replay on the web
Please let us know if you have follow up questions, so we can continue assisting. Take care!