Safari History not showing Google Searches

Question

Level 1

28 points

Safari History not showing Google Searches

Over the past day or two, I have encountered a strange problem: past Google Searches are, for the most part, not showing up on my Safari History. I say for the most part, because once out of every ten times or so for no reason in particular they do. (In addition, some (but not all) of the time, clicks from a Google Search are listed in the History not by their page title, but by the rather lengthy google search url that located them.) There are times when I want to redo a search, and it is always convenient to be able to go back to the History to find the original, so I would like to fix this problem, which I have never had before. As I said, as best as I can tell, it is only an issue with Google searches, other pages that I navigate to show up normally in my history.

I thought it might be a corrupt preferences file, so I removed both Library/Preferences/com.apple.safari.plist and the Library/Safari/History.plist files, but this did not help. I also upgraded from 5.0 to 5.0.1. Any other suggestions? Why would this only be happening with Google (I think, so far)?

MacBook Pro, Mac OS X (10.5.8)

Posted on Aug 6, 2010 9:27 AM

Reply

Answer 1

Best reply

begemot2 Author

Level 1

28 points

Aug 11, 2010 8:22 PM in response to begemot2

I still haven't figured this out, and it is still annoying, as I do like to be able to return to previous google searches in my "history." But for some reason, the Safari History does not distinguish between the Google homepage and any and all searches done from the homepage. At least one other person noticed this and posted a similar thread; it seems to have started a week or two ago -- before that all Google searches showed up individually in the Safari History.

Is there anyone who is not experiencing this apparent glitch?

Reply

Answer 2

begemot2 Author

Level 1

28 points

Aug 7, 2010 6:23 AM in response to TildeBee

Thanks for the reply, Bee, but I don't think either of those things are the issue. My history saves for a week, and I empty the cache occasionally. But, again, it is only (seems to be) searches that I do on Google that do no show up on the History, and they don't show up immediately -- that is, they never show up on the History.

Is anyone else experiencing this, or is it local to my computer for some reason?

Reply

Answer 3

TildeBee

Level 7

31,917 points

Aug 7, 2010 6:59 AM in response to begemot2

It is something on your computer.
To test:
Clear your cache and history.
Restart Safari and make Google searches.
See if they're in the History list.

If not,
Clear all your Google Cookies.
Restart SAfari.
Test again.

To find the culprit requires a process of elimination.

Message was edited by: ~Bee

Reply

Answer 4

begemot2 Author

Level 1

28 points

Aug 6, 2010 9:32 AM in response to begemot2

I just tried Firefox, and it does not have the same problem.

So it seems, as best as I can tell, to be something about the interface between Safari and Google.

Reply

Answer 5

TildeBee

Level 7

31,917 points

Aug 6, 2010 10:52 AM in response to begemot2

How long are you saving your History list?
Do you empty your Safari cache regularly?

Message was edited by: ~Bee

Reply

Answer 6

begemot2 Author

Level 1

28 points

Aug 7, 2010 7:51 AM in response to TildeBee

Thank you again, Bee. I tried both those things. On restarting, the first Google Search I do does show up in my History, but after that, they do not. It is almost as if Safari doesn't recognize the additional searches as having led to a distinct (new) page.

Reply

Answer 7

TildeBee

Level 7

31,917 points

Aug 7, 2010 8:11 AM in response to begemot2

Just a thought here . . .
Have you cleared your Google search history?
Are you using the Google search bar in Safari, or actually going to the Google page and searching from there?

Reply

Answer 8

begemot2 Author

Level 1

28 points

Aug 7, 2010 10:00 PM in response to TildeBee

I have cleared my history multiple times.

Interestingly, the problem only seems to appear when I do a search from the Google home page. When I search from the tool bar, these searches appear as normal individually on the History.

Have no idea why, but apparently I'm not the only one who has noticed this issue, which has apparently appeared during the last several days.

Reply

Answer 9

TildeBee

Level 7

31,917 points

Aug 11, 2010 9:28 PM in response to begemot2

begemot2 --
Have you read this?
Its from Google's help page.
I typed in "Google History" and got this:
http://www.google.com/support/accounts/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=54066

Here are the first two reasons Google History is not recorded:
+Web History only records your web activity while you're signed in to your Google Account. You'll know that you're signed in if you see your email address in the top right corner of your Google homepage. If you visit webpages or perform searches without signing in, they won't be recorded.+

+Web History doesn't record the addresses of webpages that are prefixed with https://.+

Interesting, eh?
Google is actually preventing history from being recorded from it's home page
unless you're signed into their site. Boo Hiss!!!!!

Reply

Answer 10

grejoh

Level 1

14 points

Aug 22, 2010 12:12 AM in response to begemot2

Google has become annoying, I personally will not sign in to an account just to back page search history. I've switched to Bing as it will save search history, just like Google did. : )

Reply

Answer 11

begemot2 Author

Level 1

28 points

Aug 23, 2010 7:44 PM in response to TildeBee

That is indeed interesting, but that is, I think, for their own web history recording (which appears to be a new feature tied to your gmail account), not the history that your browser (that is, Safari) keeps. And, as I said, Firefox does keep the Google searches one does in the History, so it seems to be something peculiar about the interface between Google and Safari. And specifically, as I mentioned above, the Google homepage and Safari, because searches entered into the toolbar searchbox DO, weirdly, get saved in the browser history.

At any rate, none of this is too big a deal, but it is odd that it just started happening a couple of weeks ago when it never used to be an issue. Since I'm in the habit of doing searches from the Google homepage, and since I frequently like to revisit these searches in my Safari History, it's just a bit of a nuisance, but it can be worked around, of course ...

Reply

Answer 12

Ed_Ok

Level 1

4 points

Sep 2, 2010 10:09 AM in response to begemot2

I have the exact same problem. I even tried that: once Google redirected me to the page I wanted, I accessed another site, then clicked the return button, but still the page wouldn't show in History even if reloaded the page. The only thing that works is to copy the page url and paste it in new tab. Only then would the page show in History. That's pretty weird and annoying...

Reply

Answer 13

Sep 2, 2010 4:00 PM in response to Ed_Ok

Same here, just sayin'

It's a noticeably trending . . . . . thing ?

Reply

Answer 14

m_stol

Level 1

0 points

Sep 6, 2010 12:10 PM in response to begemot2

Performing searches through the Search Box seems to bypass this issue. I prefer using google.ca though, so I installed the PopSearch extension and pointed the google search to that. That works as well.

These are really kludge workarounds though. The history recording algorithm in Safari 5 is definitely broken vis-a-vis Google searches from a Google search page. Neither Firefox nor Camino exhibit this strange behavior and record the search correctly within an properly labeled and retrievable link.

Reply

Answer 15

Alex T

Level 1

93 points

Oct 25, 2010 2:22 AM in response to m_stol

I have noticed exactly the same thing. Did anyone find a solution/reason for this?

Reply