Search for Completed Reminders in MacOS?

In macOS Monterey Reminders, I want to search across all my lists for a task, whether it is marked completed or not. I use this feature a lot with my various shopping lists. I'll mark something as completed once I buy it, then later mark it as incomplete when I need to purchase it again. If I try to search for "tomatoes" to add them to my shopping list, the search will return no results since "tomatoes" are marked as completed.

BTW, this is not the behavior in iOS, it will return the correct results, regardless of whether a task is marked as completed or not.