When I import media into Final Cut Pro the first second of each clip has no audio

When I import media into Final Cut Pro (FCP) from a Canon GL1 Mini DV the very first second of each and every single clip has no Audio (again just the first second of each clip) .. I am using an imac (os Big Sur 11.2) and a beginner user of FCP .. Any suggestions on how to fix this issue is greatly appreciated. Thank you


[Re-Titled by Moderator]

iMac 27″ 5K, macOS 11.2

Posted on Sep 25, 2023 9:48 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Sep 27, 2023 2:26 AM

To get a better idea of what might be going on can you be more specific of typically how many clips you get from a one hour tape? Do the number of scenes you have recorded on a tape correspond to the number of clips imported?

If for example on a one hour tape you have recorded ,say ,35 scenes ( record button pressed on and off 35 times)

then are you saying you get 35 clips into FCP? If you get 35 clips in this instance then as Luis says, that is how it should be. If you are getting more than that number ( gazillions ?), in this particular scenario , then obviously something is wrong.

Sometimes using a camcorder to play back tape that was not the original cam' that recorded it can cause import issues.

Also if the cam' recorded at LP instead of SP then again problems can occur on import.

One and a half hours of video on an "hour" tape would indicate LP mode.

Have you tried to clean the tape path and imported a tape to see if it makes a difference?


As Luis says, try QTP, but if you really are getting "gazillions = a huge number" of clips per tape then something might be going on that QTP can't even overcome.

I can understand that if you are getting a huge number of unexpected scene breaks then editing out the first second of video with missing audio may not be practical.

I would be curious to see if a short import into iMovie results in same issue or not.

Similar questions

14 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Sep 27, 2023 2:26 AM in response to Pont-9

To get a better idea of what might be going on can you be more specific of typically how many clips you get from a one hour tape? Do the number of scenes you have recorded on a tape correspond to the number of clips imported?

If for example on a one hour tape you have recorded ,say ,35 scenes ( record button pressed on and off 35 times)

then are you saying you get 35 clips into FCP? If you get 35 clips in this instance then as Luis says, that is how it should be. If you are getting more than that number ( gazillions ?), in this particular scenario , then obviously something is wrong.

Sometimes using a camcorder to play back tape that was not the original cam' that recorded it can cause import issues.

Also if the cam' recorded at LP instead of SP then again problems can occur on import.

One and a half hours of video on an "hour" tape would indicate LP mode.

Have you tried to clean the tape path and imported a tape to see if it makes a difference?


As Luis says, try QTP, but if you really are getting "gazillions = a huge number" of clips per tape then something might be going on that QTP can't even overcome.

I can understand that if you are getting a huge number of unexpected scene breaks then editing out the first second of video with missing audio may not be practical.

I would be curious to see if a short import into iMovie results in same issue or not.

Sep 26, 2023 1:31 AM in response to Pont-9

Might be worth checking that this issue is not " on the tape "

Have you played tape back on the Canon's built in lcd screen and speaker to check that audio is there for this initial second in time?


Hopefully you don't think this next question is stupid but is it essential that you have this first second of video minus it's audio in your timeline. If not then just cut this first second of recording out.

Sep 27, 2023 8:22 AM in response to thesurreyfriends

I tried importing using QuickTime Player and so far so good it works like a charm knock on wood .. it’s Tabula Rasa time for me starting from scratch importing hundreds of hours old tapes all over again ..


I hope FCP revisits its import media functions unless they moved on beyond good old video tapes.


So just an observation, here is a quick side by side comp. between importing using QT vs my previous way using FCP as far as generated file sizes .. with QT player the resulting .mov file for an hour long DV tape recorded as SP was around 20 GB ( I used max vs high quality) and when imported into FCP into a new Library and pushed to the timeline creating a project the resulting library size doubled to 40 GB  .. unlike my previous way of importing with FCP using the same exact tape resulted in a 14GB .mov file and the library file size interestingly enough stayed the exact same size of 14 GB after I created a project and dumped the imported .mov file in the timeline and created a project exactly as I did using the QT route above .. 


Anyways I’m glad QT player works for me so far so good (cross finger) and I truly appreciate all your responses out there.


PS .. FCP is still my favorite app but not so much when it comes to capturing good old video tapes.


Thanks again

Sep 25, 2023 11:58 PM in response to Pont-9

I don't know if this will help, but anyway: you may try to import using Quicktime Player instead.

FCP will break the tape into multiple clips.

Quicktime Player can import a whole tape, you want, or any portion thereof, as a single clip.

Then you may impory this clip to FCP, like you would import any other clip that is already in your drive. By importing all at once, I expect that this problem is sound cutting on the first second will be moot. You can then use FCP to mark, favorite or reject parts of that clip.

Sep 27, 2023 9:32 AM in response to Pont-9

Do you have Background Rendering enabled in FCP Preferences? That may cause the library to become bloated. To delete the render cache. Select the library in the browser, choose File->Delete Generated Library Files... Choose All Render files.


Unless FCP is having trouble playing back, disable Background Rendering.

Manage render files in Final Cut Pro for Mac - Apple Support 


Sep 27, 2023 2:15 PM in response to thesurreyfriends

Thank you for the follow-up .. yes here is an example of a DV tape having around 20 long continuous takes totaling an hour .. when imported thru FCP I got a little over 1,000 separate clips with the audio as you know dropping off the very first second of each one of those clips .. again I wished I found out about this FCP flaw earlier before I imported hundreds of hours .. but that’s behind be now and already restarted captures using QT player and looks promising so far .. 


I experimented with overlapping audio from the left clip over to the right adjacent clip by double-clicking the audio channel on the left and drag its edge over to cover that one missing second of audio to its right ..  unless there is a batch command/ macro to automate these operations it’s a pain to go thru this thousands of times ..


other weeded-out possibilities .. the camera is in top condition with heads clean and the tapes all master quality properly stored on their edge (not flat on their face).

Sep 26, 2023 10:48 AM in response to Luis Sequeira1

Thank you much Luis and surrey friends (hereon below)for your responses truly appreciate your time and efforts, I can definitely try other means of importing my dv tapes but I like to resolve this issue sticking with Final Cut Pro app first since I already imported hundreds of hours thru FCP (my bad without running a timeline editing test run first .. I did not notice these one second audio drops until I started editing my projects) the issue is not on the original tapes and for some reason or another FCP randomly chops my original footage into gazillion clips with no rhyme or reason which I’m fine with, except for these one(1) second audio drop-outs at the start of each and every clip .. so I need to get this issue resolved using FCP even if I have to re-import my media all over again through FCP.   I am not familiar with the community discussion inhere and not sure whether or not Final Cut Pro tech support follow these discussions here.

Sep 27, 2023 8:49 AM in response to Pont-9

The manual isn't clear on why FCP would stop now that I looked into it. They should clarify what "The end of the tape is reached" specifically means:


"Importing begins immediately from the current location on the tape and continues until one of the following occurs:

  • The end of the tape is reached.
  • The storage device you’re importing to is full.
  • You stop the import session by clicking Stop Import or Close (to close the Media Import window) or by pressing Escape."


Import into Final Cut Pro for Mac from tape-based cameras - Apple Support


Sep 27, 2023 10:16 AM in response to W. Raider

W. Raider wrote:

• The manual isn't clear on why FCP would stop now that I looked into it. They should clarify what "The end of the tape is reached" specifically means:

"Importing begins immediately from the current location on the tape and continues until one of the following occurs:
The end of the tape is reached.
• The storage device you’re importing to is full.
• You stop the import session by clicking Stop Import or Close (to close the Media Import window) or by pressing Escape."

Import into Final Cut Pro for Mac from tape-based cameras - Apple Support


If you record, then stop, record, then stop, and so on, on one tape, then FCP will import the whole tape, and each of these times you recorded and then stopped will be a separate clip. That is consistent with what the manual says. You can think of each these sections of the tape with continuous recording (and hence continuous timecode) as one "clip" in your tape, just as it would on a card based camera. Does that make sense?


Sep 27, 2023 1:32 PM in response to Pont-9

Good that you found a way forward with QTP.


I am still curious to know how many clips you typically obtained when importing a one hour tape into FCP.

20 to say 100 clips might not be regarded as unusual but 300 or more might, and would therefore suggest that an error is occurring with the import apart from the missing audio that you are aware of.

Did the number of clips correspond with the number of scene breaks ( record start/stop) or did you get many more clips than scene breaks. Just trying to get a measure of your interpretation of the quantity of gazillion.

Hundreds of clips, thousands of clips???

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

When I import media into Final Cut Pro the first second of each clip has no audio

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.