Well, looking at the actual file shows the size to be as you stated and thus within parameters: evidently the forum software had increased the size in reformatting it.
Looking at your podcast in the Podcast app (on Catalina) showes the old image, but subscribing (where the feed is read directly) shows the new one: it can take several days for the online podcast to catch up so that is probably the explanation, and it's just a question of waiting provided you changed the name of the image. Obviously I can't check that. If you didn't it, won't update because Podcasts caches the image and so it would have no way of knowing the image had changed.