Why do comments in Numbers no longer appear when the pointer hovers or a cell is selected?

This has appeared to have been the case ever since Sonoma, at least. I upgraded Numbers, no go.


I can add comments, I can use all the 'hide/show' menu commands, but hovering or clicking no longer shows the comments bubbles.


Is it turned off? Can it be turned back on? Or is it just a bug in Sonoma or Numbers?


This was in a couple of older documents, so I created a brand-new document and added a comment to a cell as a test. Still no go.


M1 MBP. (apple is listing an older iMac with an older OS—I don't use it anymore. The problem is on my M1 MBP with MacOS v14.)

iMac 27″

Posted on Oct 20, 2023 1:57 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Oct 21, 2023 1:17 PM

The first things I did were to make sure I was on 14.0, Numbers 13.2, quit and restart Numbers, and restart the computer.


The next thing I did was verify 'show comments' was on, then toggled back-and-forth from hide to show.


It still does not show a comment when hovering.


So this may all turn on what you mean by 'working as expected'. I expected the comments to show when I HOVERED The pointer anywhere over the cell. That has been what 'working as expected' has been for as long as I can remember.


What I discovered lately is that this just does not happen.


But, if I click directly on the little triangle, that is now apparently a disclosure triangle. Do that, and the comment bubble appears.


Here is what seems to have happened: Having comment bubbles appear every time your pointer traverses the boundary of a cell containing a comment is annoying as ****. We only have an intent when we want to see the comment—when we have that intent, and hovering does not imply an intent. Often all that implies is that is where your pointer might be for a split second as you move the pointer from place to place on the screen.



By 'quietly', I mean they told no one. This means that expected behavior is now missing. That's not a good thing, bc when things behave unexpectedly, we perceive a potential problem with the software. That's the functional equivalent of pulling your Glock, racking the slide, pointing it at your foot, and firing.


I consider it an improvement. What boggles my mind is why they did not alert us to what is actually an improvement to Numbers.


[Edited by Moderator]

Similar questions

3 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Oct 21, 2023 1:17 PM in response to SGIII

The first things I did were to make sure I was on 14.0, Numbers 13.2, quit and restart Numbers, and restart the computer.


The next thing I did was verify 'show comments' was on, then toggled back-and-forth from hide to show.


It still does not show a comment when hovering.


So this may all turn on what you mean by 'working as expected'. I expected the comments to show when I HOVERED The pointer anywhere over the cell. That has been what 'working as expected' has been for as long as I can remember.


What I discovered lately is that this just does not happen.


But, if I click directly on the little triangle, that is now apparently a disclosure triangle. Do that, and the comment bubble appears.


Here is what seems to have happened: Having comment bubbles appear every time your pointer traverses the boundary of a cell containing a comment is annoying as ****. We only have an intent when we want to see the comment—when we have that intent, and hovering does not imply an intent. Often all that implies is that is where your pointer might be for a split second as you move the pointer from place to place on the screen.



By 'quietly', I mean they told no one. This means that expected behavior is now missing. That's not a good thing, bc when things behave unexpectedly, we perceive a potential problem with the software. That's the functional equivalent of pulling your Glock, racking the slide, pointing it at your foot, and firing.


I consider it an improvement. What boggles my mind is why they did not alert us to what is actually an improvement to Numbers.


[Edited by Moderator]

Oct 21, 2023 9:34 PM in response to thomas192

thomas192 wrote:


I expected the comments to show when I HOVERED The pointer anywhere over the cell.

Yes, that is what I expected too. And that's the behavior I observe on my machine. No change from previous behavior, I think.


If you're seeing something different then there may be something specific to your machine.


SG



This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Why do comments in Numbers no longer appear when the pointer hovers or a cell is selected?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.