Macbook (Late 2006 13”): lack of destination for the installer+Data securely erased?

Hi.

In the process of helping a friend migrate Macbook’s I’ve ended up a bit stuck. I’ve got them with their new computer okay but I’ve struggled in trying to safely wipe their old Macbook in order to sell/gift it safely without their sensitive data being retrievable. Sadly, the Apple telephone assistant that I got through to was unable to really do anything for me, as she insisted that this stuff was no longer in their support remit. So now I am here. Here goes..

The Macbook (Late 2006 13”) wouldn’t hold on to the Snow Leopard installation disk so I used the original installer disk that came with the Macbook in 2007 (Tiger, at this point?), and booted up from this disk. From the menu bar I selected Utilities: Disk Utility. All fine so far, but then every time I’d try to do a disk erase it would run for an hour or so before stopping with an error message (see pic.). Now when I power on I (eventually!) get the installer: select language, etc. All fine but when I’ve agreed to the licence agreement we get to the ‘select a destination’ page but there is no destination. See picture

So, my appeal is twofold:

Firstly, how can I resolve the lack of destination for the installer (that I also can’t seem to eject!).

Secondly, is there a any chance that the aforementioned running of the security erase option has had any desired effect, given that it failed to complete on three occasions?

Help gratefully received. Thanks

Earlier Mac models

Posted on Nov 2, 2023 2:03 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Nov 3, 2023 10:50 AM

The I/O error is an indication the disk has failed. It will not be displayed until many repeated attempts already failed. Eventually it gives up, and that dialog appears.


The fact the disk no longer appears at all is more confirmation of that fact.


Disk Utility's "secure erase" feature was never able to provide absolute assurance that its data could never be retrieved, given essentially unlimited amounts of time and / or money to invest in that effort. It complied with published standards at the time, but those standards have since been superseded in favor of full disk encryption which FileVault provided. If that Mac's startup disk was encrypted with FileVault no additional action is required. You may dispose of the Mac in its present condition, or sell / donate it with the knowledge its disk is inoperative.

Similar questions

3 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Nov 3, 2023 10:50 AM in response to Gadvox

The I/O error is an indication the disk has failed. It will not be displayed until many repeated attempts already failed. Eventually it gives up, and that dialog appears.


The fact the disk no longer appears at all is more confirmation of that fact.


Disk Utility's "secure erase" feature was never able to provide absolute assurance that its data could never be retrieved, given essentially unlimited amounts of time and / or money to invest in that effort. It complied with published standards at the time, but those standards have since been superseded in favor of full disk encryption which FileVault provided. If that Mac's startup disk was encrypted with FileVault no additional action is required. You may dispose of the Mac in its present condition, or sell / donate it with the knowledge its disk is inoperative.

Nov 3, 2023 6:06 PM in response to Gadvox

A disk that doesn't work has no value, unless you are fond of disassembling them to remove their very powerful magnets and / or repurpose the shiny platters as decorative ornaments.


There may be value in the data they contain, but whoever wanted it would need significant motivation to invest the time and expense in extracting it, with no guarantee of success.


If you remain concerned about that possibility the only practicable solution is physical destruction; one of the options discussed in the NIST Special Publication 800-88 Guidelines for Media Sanitization. "Disintegrate, Pulverize, Melt, and Incinerate" for example.


Other, equally effective methods are left to your imagination. NIST does not address them, and this site may not be an appropriate place to discuss them. They are my favorite techniques though.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Macbook (Late 2006 13”): lack of destination for the installer+Data securely erased?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.