Can't Unmount Volume to Reinstall MacOS

Did you try running First Aid while booted into Recovery Mode? If you are using an Intel Mac, then try booting into Internet Recovery Mode using Command + Option + R instead to access the most recent version of macOS installer. Unfortunately some Macs may only boot to the oldest online installer instead regardless of the key used for booting.

Within Disk Utility you can select the volume and click the "Unmount" button. If you are planning to erase the drive anyway, then force unmounting is Ok.

If your Mac still boots normally or into Safe Mode, then I highly recommend creating a bootable macOS USB installer so you may more options available (2018-2020 Intel Macs probably won't work in many cases to boot from USB especially if the internal SSD has been erased). If you have an Apple Silicon Mac, then you can use a firmware "Restore" to push a clean OS onto the internal SSD if you have access to another Mac running macOS 12.4+.

FYI, it really helps to know the exact model Mac so we can narrow down the possible suggestions to just your particular hardware.

I have two points to share. First, try reinstalling in the Safe Mode (hold down the Shift key on restart). Second when Disk Utility reports that there is a problem with a disk it may require multiple scans before reporting an ok result.

It would be nice to know what finally solved the issue for you, so others who find this thread will know as well.