Is there a Physical Solution to quieting a Macbook Pro

There was a question on how to help with a physical solution to quiet a macbookpro while recording in a home studio. There were many helpful answers on how to work with your macbook pro: elevate it, put it in another room, buy a new macbook pro that is quiet etc...but this does not help me. I am looking for a physical solution...ie. a soundproof box, or what I can do physically to isolate my computer, because even after following all the good wisdom out there that I have done and followed, thus allowing for good improvement, I still am working my computer a lot and inevitably the fan kicks on and in a quiet recording and the recording is ruined. The answer cannot be mic placement (tried), nor buying a new computer, (cant afford) nor elevating the computer (tried)...etc as was well given. I am looking for a physical solution of isloating my macbook pro. I cannot punch a whole through the wall. But perhaps I can run a long cord over 30 feet into another room and isolate it that way.... I looked at a isobox by orsy, but it is 3.4K dollars... too pricy for me. IF there is no answer, so be it, but am throwing the question out there. Thanks in advance for your help. Michael

MacBook Pro 16″, macOS 14.1

Posted on Jan 13, 2024 9:05 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Jan 15, 2024 9:04 AM

You know that a proper studio separates the equipment from the mics by using the isolation booth that the artist -and the mics- would be in. So you know separating the mics from the MBP is the best solution.


Isolation in another room is the ideal, but remote control has to be worked out. With a wireless keyboard and mouse and a cable run under a door for a remote monitor and you're in business. Better yet, AirPlay the MBP to a monitor via AppleTV box. I don't think that would be cost prohibitive.

Similar questions

9 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Jan 15, 2024 9:04 AM in response to MaechaelMusic

You know that a proper studio separates the equipment from the mics by using the isolation booth that the artist -and the mics- would be in. So you know separating the mics from the MBP is the best solution.


Isolation in another room is the ideal, but remote control has to be worked out. With a wireless keyboard and mouse and a cable run under a door for a remote monitor and you're in business. Better yet, AirPlay the MBP to a monitor via AppleTV box. I don't think that would be cost prohibitive.

Jan 15, 2024 9:39 AM in response to D.I. Johnson

Thanks D.I - This is the kind of answer I am seeking. I agree. I need to figure out how to isolate the MBP. I unfortunately, cannot afford an isolation booth right now...so am looking for ways to isolate the MBP. In the interim I have found two solutions:


  1. Run TG Pro software app (only 10 dollars) that helps me to controls the fans, and if necessary, for just the time of the take to quiet the fans, to turn them off for a 3 minute take.. I have tried it and so far it allows me to set the gradations of the fans to be cooler sooner, so the heavy fan does not need to kick in. Understand I need to be prudent to not overheat the mac
  2. Buy a Cal Digit Thunderbolt 4...docking station. This will allow me, per your good advice to run a long cable from the MBP outside of the room to the Cal Digit, and then connect my Digital Analog interface, keyboard, Display, etc. to the CAL Digit without having my computer needing to be on the desk. This also will allow me to never have the fans off..


So the combo of these two might help me in the short run until I can figure out how to afford a booth. because ultimately I agree, I need a booth, but need some success first :-) that might generate income to move to that step.


I was thinking some kind of isolation booth for the computer itself, but apparently there is nothing out there for that and then you run into ventilation problems that would inevitably make the fan challenge worse.


Think I am good with the great inputs given to me by the community. THANKS everyone for this help. If anyone also has another idea...I am open.

Jan 13, 2024 9:26 AM in response to MaechaelMusic

Welcome!


Please help us help you. What exactly is noisy? Fans?


Fan speeds should only ramp up when the computer heats up and that will happen faster in an insulated box.


Is it alert sounds from apps or the OS? The old-school fix was to cut the audio plug from a dead set of headphones or earphones and stick in the audio out port. That mutes the speakers, at least on older Macs.


Is this about the 16-inch Macbook Pro running macOS 14 shown in your equipment line? I have to ask because the forum software quite often shows the wrong devices.

Jan 13, 2024 11:34 AM in response to Allan Jones

Hi Allan - Thanks so much for your answer. The noise comes from the fans. It is a 2019 16 inch MB Pro; Processor 2.3 GHz 8-Core Intel Core i9; Graphics AMD Radeon Pro 5500M 4 GB Intel UHD Graphics 630 1536 MB; Memory 64 GB 2667 MHz DDR4. Have cleared memory, raised the computer to allow air, and followed all the advise the universe can give...but I use the computer a lot with a lot or processing of plugins (even with the proper input buffer size) and as would any normal computer, the fan comes on..eventually, quite loudly like a jet engine :-)...I then pick this up in microphones. So the answer I am seeking is a physical solution to isolate the normal functioning of the mac (fan should come on) to avoid picking up the fan noise with an intricate silence of guitar picking. How can I isolate my mac? Is there any kind of small isolation booth for a computer, with lots of ventilation area? Thanks. Michael

Jan 13, 2024 11:32 AM in response to MaechaelMusic

Also, I have run a diagnostic of my computer (shut the computer off then turn on while pressing 'D') and all is well with my computer: Tip Top. Still, even now as I am typing I hear the soft normal and to be expected whirl of the fan...a fan noise that I pick up in my microphones, a fan noise that I wish to physically isolate. Thus the search for a needed, physical solution of isolating the normal sound of a computer and how to do so. M.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Is there a Physical Solution to quieting a Macbook Pro

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.