Apple Event: May 7th at 7 am PT

On a Windows computer, can I use the new Apple Music app to add a CD to my library?

If I subscribe to Apple Music or iTunes Match, I can use iTunes to import the contents of a physical CD to my iTunes library, whence I can sync it to all my devices. Having downloaded the new Apple Music app on my windows computer, I cannot see how to import a CD. Do I have to keep iTunes on my computer solely for this purpose?

Windows, Windows 10

Posted on Feb 8, 2024 6:43 AM

Reply
Question marked as Best reply

Posted on Feb 8, 2024 3:39 PM

As someone who still believes in physical media and manages 1000s of songs in itunes from ripped CDs, this is a potentially big issue.

For years I've been using iTunes downloaded from apple.com (not the windows app) to manage my music and apple devices on various PCs. From reading the new Apple Music for Windows guide, it doesn't look like there is any ability to rip CDs into your music library like iTunes could. It also looks like when you install Apple Music/TV/Devices, you can no longer use iTunes for your music library.

Since Apple mentions iTunes is still needed to access podcasts and audio books, can iTunes still rip CDs once Apple Music is installed?

In theory if you're running Win 10 or 11, you should be able to rip a CD using the newer updated Windows Media Player (replaced Groove). Then use the new Apple Music app to import the ripped files into your music library, and then the Devices app to transfer to your Apple device. But I wouldn't recommend being the guinea pig.

For now I'm sticking with iTunes 12.13.1.3. But I'm concerned that we'll eventually be forced to use the Apple Devices app to stay current and manage our iphones and ipods which will then require the music/tv apps and shut out iTunes ... meaning no way to rip our physical media libraries.

If iTunes currently allows ripping and listening to CDs, how was it omitted from the Music app ??

31 replies

Feb 18, 2024 1:09 PM in response to mblazer78

I found a software package from NCH Software in Australia that can read CDs into a variety of file formats. Apple lossless is not among them, but FLAC is. I would expect that if you put a CD into your iCloud library and Apple already knows about the title, they will play it back in lossless format; but I would also expect that if you were to import it in FLAC form in the first place, it would be more likely to be lossless on playback.


I did successfully read a CD that I had purchased into .m4a format and imported it into my Apple Music library, and when I played it back, it showed up as being lossless. I did the same thing with another, much more obscure (i.e., self-published by my cousin) CD, and that one did not show up as lossless, so I am pretty sure that they're doing something like matching against the database of commercial CDs they know about.

Feb 21, 2024 8:54 AM in response to arkoenig

I’m running windows 10 and I did the same thing, thought iTunes had locked out the music option after I’d uninstalled all of the new Apple apps - but I clicked the heading that said ‘audiobooks’ in iTunes when I opened the program up again and music was there, in the list of options. I clicked it and there was everything, as usual. Could be the case with you (hopefully).

Feb 28, 2024 11:47 AM in response to GustafEriksson

Nope. Installing the Apple Music app automagically changes the behavior of iTunes so that the only thing it will let you do is listen to podcasts. You can't even use it to back up your device any more--you have to use the Apple Devices app for that purpose.


And removing the Apple Music app does not change the behavior of iTunes back to how it worked previously.

Feb 28, 2024 12:14 PM in response to arkoenig

Missread your initial post 😅 But yeah, sadly enough you have to keep iTunes ripping CD's for now. Also, Apple Music adn Apple Devices is crazy unstable...


My old answer:

Wierd... I'm ripping a CD right now, so yes, it should work. The only issue is that the files don't show up automatically in Apple Music as they are imported to the Music/iTunes/iTunes Media/Audiobooks folder.

And yeah, I have iTunes and Apple Music installed. As well as Apple Devices. My iTunes have support for Podcasts, Audiobooks and importing CD's.


Mar 22, 2024 11:33 AM in response to Mr.Tennis

It took a while for me to figure this out, but even when Apple Music and Apple Devices are installed (which means that iTunes is crippled to only display audiobooks and podcasts), CDs can still be ripped in iTunes.


Open iTunes, put a CD in your CD drive, iTunes will prompt you to rip it (say yes) and wait until it's done. Once it's all done, go into "Recently Added" and you'll see everything you just ripped, but under "Audiobooks". Select everything and then drag-and-drop into Apple Music. That will then copy everything to the music folder in Apple Music (i.e. you old iTunes media folder). Then delete what you just ripped in the "Audiobook" folder.


Very much extra work, but it does work. Apple needs to fix this so we can do it all in Apple Music.

Mar 27, 2024 2:39 PM in response to grrldive

Yes. iTunes and Apple Music both have different default Library locations.


Go to C:\Users\yourname\Music. Once there, you'll see two folders: "AppleMusic" and "iTunes". For Apple Music, the music library is in a subfolder called "Media\Music", and for iTunes, the music library is under "iTunes Media\Music".


All my music consists of ripped CDs and it used to be in the iTunes. I kept it in the iTunes library but changed the default location in Apple Music.


Pain in the rear and Apple definitely didn't think this out before release. The only thing I like about Apple Music is that it has dark mode.



Apr 2, 2024 7:20 AM in response to arkoenig

Hello there, I am also hesitant to migrate to the new Apple Music App on Windows due to the missing features and reported instability.


Does anyone know if the new Apple Music App can still create AAC versions from other formats like wav or alac? Previously in iTunes you could select a track, then go to “File”, “Convert”, “Create AAC Version” (translated from German iTunes).?

Apr 21, 2024 10:02 AM in response to arkoenig

I was stumped by this issue. And stuffed by my iPhone not taking all songs from an album I had ripped from a CD (that I bought from a record shop, yes, old school), as it would only import some of the album to the phone yet show me via Apple Music that the phone contained all of those songs.

So I uninstalled iTunes, and installed Music and Devices as instructed by Apple Support to my Windows computer. And with these installed we cannot import from CD to Music app.

As per Brocktoon623 reply above, I ripped the CD using Media Player on Windows (thanks Brocktoon623, great tip) and then drag and dropped the album to Music. Then I have to sync the phone using the Devices app, and finally the album is imported to my phone.

Come on Apple, it was so much easier with iTunes.

Apr 22, 2024 8:50 PM in response to arkoenig

I "ripped" my music CD using the old iTunes app, which placed the files in the Podcasts bucket. I found the music files via Explorer in Win 11, created a folder that was named according to the name of the CD, and moved the music files to that folder. Next, I found the appropriate location in the C-drive Music-->iTunes-->iTunes Media-->Music folder for the new folder and moved it to that location. Finally, I used Apple Music app to add the new folder to the Apple Music app. Regrettably, the album artwork didn't follow. So I found the artwork JPG file using my Internet search engine, saved the file to an artwork folder in my Documents folder, and then used the Apple Music app to add the artwork to the album. This involved a right click on the place where the album artwork should appear and a left click on Properties. I selected "...edit information for multiple items..." and then selected the Artwork tab and added the JPG artwork file. The artwork immediately appeared with each individual song but took a little time to appear on the Apple Music album desktop. Although the iTunes situation has been quite trying for some time now, the new Apple Music and Apple TV apps show promise.

On a Windows computer, can I use the new Apple Music app to add a CD to my library?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.