Please review the Apple Support article I linked below. You need to change the order of the payment methods in your Apple ID Account (not your Wallet app).
>>Reorder payment methods on your iPhone, iPad, or Apple Vision Pro
- On the Payment & Shipping screen, tap Edit.
- Touch and hold a payment method to drag it further up or down your list of payment methods. Apple will attempt to charge your payment methods in the order that they appear.
- Tap Done.<<
If you already have a payment method on file, learn how to change or update your payment method.
Add a payment method - Apple Support
How apps, content, and subscriptions from Apple are billed - Apple Support