Super glue on pairing button of AirPod Pros

I super glued a Tile Sticker on top of the pairing button. Now that my new iPhone that needs pairing, I find that sometimes the Connect message on the Pros doesn’t show, but even when it does, the pairing button does not work. I already tried Goo Gone and WD-40 as recommended for something else, but no luck. PS I don’t know what I was thinking either!

Thank you in advance for any information