When searching for an artist, then selecting the songs tab, Apple Music won't keep playing from results.

So when I search for an artist, then select the Songs tab, then select, for instance, the top song in the list, Apple Music won't keep playing songs on the list. The behavior I expect (as Spotify does) is for it to play the next song in the list. In fact, it plays a completely different artist 100% of the time. What gives? Do I have a setting wrong?