I was trying to reformat an old MacBook Pro which can only be upgraded upto Catlina on its HDD but its not working.

Basically I received an old device which was experiencing fragmentation related hang ups, so I did what you would normally do on any operating system installed on a HDD which is to format the drive and reinstall the OS. I went into recovery mode, selected the top most option in the hierarchy to format (in Disk Utility), and then I had to choose the file system format. I read on these forums that mac os extended is the way to go for HDDs so I reformatted from AFPS to mac os extended and it worked. But after I reinstalled Catalina on it the end result was that it reverted back to its original format which was AFPS.


I tried reinstalling from a bootable drive but there was no difference. I also found out on this forum that many users were experiencing problems upgrading to Catalina because it requires AFPS. So is the installer re-reformatting my drive during reinstallation? Is it impossible to install Catalina on a drive formatted to mac os extended? Is it possible to find out the original drive format and scheme the device was originally setup with?

Posted on May 25, 2024 12:29 AM

Reply

Similar questions

2 replies

May 25, 2024 5:09 AM in response to daanisch

So is the installer re-reformatting my drive during reinstallation?


Yes.


Is it impossible to install Catalina on a drive formatted to mac os extended?


Yes.


Is it possible to find out the original drive format and scheme the device was originally setup with?


Depends on how old that "old device" is. You will need to boot Recovery mode and reformat the startup volume. If it predated Catalina yes you can reformat it using one of the Mac OS Extended formats — which you originally did. However, that does not convey any particular benefit. Which leads us to...


I also found out on this forum that many users were experiencing problems upgrading to Catalina because it requires AFPS.


That's an unsubstantiated claim. macOS upgrade problems are almost always due to old / incompatible / abandoned software, various and sundry "cleaning" scam products... that sort of thing. APFS conveys only benefits. Most of those benefits are lost on traditional hard disk drives but APFS itself does not cause problems; it addressed certain limitations that had been present in HFS since the beginning. Other than that it's just a file storage protocol like any other.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

I was trying to reformat an old MacBook Pro which can only be upgraded upto Catlina on its HDD but its not working.

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.