Unable to add a fingerprint (Sonoma on Intel Mac). It asks for admin password, then nothing happens

On the Touch ID and Password section of settings, there is a 'Add Fingerprint' section with a plus sign above it. If I press that plus sign, it asks for my admin password, which I provide, and then nothing happens.

If I press the plus button again, it asks for my admin password again, and nothing happens again.

There are some toggles below it, which require an admin password to shift, but after I provide it, it just shifts back. But I guess the the toggles are useless until there is a finger print.

Additional Details:

I used migration assistant from a Sonoma M2 mac to port my profile onto the intel mac, after the intel mac was wiped clean. When going through the setup, it never asked to set up a fingerprint, like it normally does with a mac setup.