Should I get an SSD to boot Sonoma to my 2019 27" iMac?

Without reciting 9 months of painful problems after upgrading my Retina 5k, 27 inch, 2019 iMac (currently 16 GB RAM and 2 TB storage memory) to Sonoma, at Apple's suggestion I have reverted to Ventura. At least part of the problem, which no one will say out loud, seems to be the Fusion Drive in the iMac. My iMac again seems fine, which it was before Sonoma. However, I cannot do a Time Machine restore of backups for the last 9 months when Sonoma was installed, which means I cannot access years of Mail folders that I really need. To allow that restoration, a senior Apple tech advisor and some third parties have suggested I by-pass the Fusion Drive by buying an SSD, installing Sonoma, and making the SSD the boot drive. The alternative seems to be to buy a new $$$$ iMac and give up my cherished 27" display (the largest display is now 24" instead of 27" - ggrrrr!!).


That brings me to my questions (I am not a techie - hopefully some of you are!):

1. I have read enough posts about people having problems with SSDs so I wonder if this solution is advisable (frying pan to the fire?).

2. Does the SSD completely replace my iMac drives so that I lose access to its 2 TB storage memory (in other words, is it like a completely new computer, but using my iMac display)?

3. With new iMacs, Apple talks of "unified memory" instead of RAM. What does the SSD do for RAM, and do I have to watch RAM specs for purposes of my large iMovie projects?

4. I have a partitioned Seagate 8 TB drive that I used for Time Machine backup (4TB) and file storage - mostly video/photo storage (4TB), which is connected via USB-A. Can I still use the Seagate for these purposes? If so, do I need a hub?

5. Will Time Machine backup whatever is on the SSD to the Seagate partition for Time Machine?

6. If I format the SSD as Mac OS Extended (journaled), will Searchlight be able to search it (I don't need to be able to use Windows files).

7. Are there other issues of which I need to be aware?


Thanks!

iMac 27″

Posted on Aug 21, 2024 3:07 PM

Reply
7 replies

Aug 21, 2024 5:15 PM in response to Eliot Hudson

My wife has an iMac with a fusion drive. Fusion drives can be problematic when they split, although that has not happened with her iMac. To be safe, I did what Apple suggested that you do. I installed an external SSD. Used Disk Utility to reformat it and used Migration Assistant to transfer all her data and apps. Set the SSD up as the startup disk. No problem. Works great. You may have to reset Time Machine to do its backups to the Seagate drive. Don't make a big deal out of this. It's a fairly straight forward process. Note - some drives come with a maintenance app on them. Do NOT use it. Erase it. They almost always cause problems.

Aug 21, 2024 10:08 PM in response to Eliot Hudson

What I am suggesting is that you install the SSD and use it as a replacement for your existing drives. External drives do not have any RAM. That is installed in your Mac and works with whatever drive you choose to use. The new SSD should meet or exceed the storage capacity you currently have so you can transfer all your files and apps onto it. Once it is set up as I suggested above it will function as your current drives do in all respects.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Should I get an SSD to boot Sonoma to my 2019 27" iMac?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.