random-user-name,
You do need to realize that even if there are 5,000 articles on the net and 5,000 people here concerned about upgrading, that that is a minuscule amount of people compared to the actual number of people using iOS 18.
To answer your question, most of the chatter here (mine included when this article first posted) was surrounded by the fact that most people don’t like change, myself included to a certain extent. I did not know anything about the change in the Photos app when I upgraded to iOS 18 (automatically). I was pretty upset when I found out how much the Photos app had changed. However, after reading a few articles and reading what some of the people have said here, I’ve learned that there is a lot of value in the new Photos app. Yes, it’s not exactly like the old one, however, it’s better in many ways. It’s customizable. I’m not sure how much of the thread here you have read, however, I would encourage you to read every single post. You may find there’s a lot of encouragement also.
I would also like to suggest that you to back up your “camera phone” to your computer when not using the cloud. If you’re going to use a separate phone for taking pictures, if for some reason, something happened to that phone, you would lose everything.
I have thought about suggesting the scenario you alluding to, to buy an older phone, like an X or an 11 and not updated to iOS 18. Then, on your newer phone, update to iOS 18 and play with the Photos app and learn how to best use it to your advantage. After a bit of time, I’m pretty sure you would not be as horrified by the update as it seems that many people are here. Take contributor Foxfire64 for instance. He waited a long time only to find out that everything worked for him.
BTW, if you don’t want your phone to automatically update, you can go to Settings, General, Software Update, and tap on Automatic Updates at the top of the page. On the next page, turn Off “Automatic Updates”.
Leave On “Security Response & System Update”
And you can choose to turn Off or leave On “iOS Updates”. If you leave this On your phone will simply download the new software to your phone, but will not install it until you choose to update. If you turn it Off, when you are ready to update your phone, it will take a little bit longer for it to download and then update.
I trust this has helped you and anyone else concerned about the new iOS 18 and the new Photos app.
Thank you!