I believe I have found the problem. I was using a SAMSUNG T9 SSD with files recorded from an atem switcher. I did not reformat the drive after purchase, and was using the original format that came on the drive (exfat) which if you look at the info under sharing it has "customized" sharing permissions(?) So if you're using one of these drives out of the box, FCP11 will not bring the files over, and will make it an alias no matter what you do. I dragged the files off the SSD and onto my desktop (which will work) then imported them in and they transferred over just fine. If you try to import from the Samsung T9, it will not, and will not give you any error messages also, no matter how hard you try or setting to copy to library. It just won't do it. Lesson learned, always format your ssd, even if it's new. Check your ssd sharing permissions on your external ssd, or maybe it's just exfat formatting (?) I'm not a techno wizard so it still may be something else particular with these drives. Samsung and Apple never liked playing well together. I blame Samsung.....