Switch Phones iPhone Mirroring macOS Sequoia

I have 2 phones, a work and personal. MacOS is set up to my work account. I realized with the iPhone mirroring, I could connect my personal phone to Mac and then be able to iMessage off either account from my desktop. Work account through macOS iMessage and personal off phone mirroring iMessage.

I disconnected my work phone and then when I go to reestablish a new connection to my other phone, it only looks for my work phone.

Any help?