How do I prevent Finder tabs from changing when switching desktops in macOS?

If I have Finder open on Desktop 1, looking at the second of three open tabs, I switch focus to a different application on Desktop 2, I then select the Finder icon in the dock, focus will return to Finder on Desktop 1 but it will have switched to a different Finder tab (i.e. the first or third tab).


(note: this issue occurs when Finder is assigned to a specific desktop or none , if I have Finder on all Desktops the issue can not occur as I would never switch desktops to get to Finder)


The following are the steps required to reproduce the issue:

  1. I open Finder on Desktop 1 with three tabs, lets call them Tab-1, Tab-2, and Tab-3
  2. The active tab is Tab-2 before I change to a different application on Desktop 2
  3. If I select the Finder icon from the Dock (and occasionally if I Cmd+Tab) I will return to Finder on Desktop 1 but the active tab will be either Tab-1 or Tab-3.
  4. If I select Tab-2 and repeat these steps, when focus return to Finder it will change to the same tab as before (i.e. if it switches to Tab-3 when focus returns once, it will switch to Tab-3 every time provided I don't open/close any other tabs)


I've attempted everything I've been able to find online for similar issues including:

  1. Reseting all Finder settings to new by deleting the config files
  2. Booting into Safe Mode and logging in as a different user


The issue has persisted despite my best efforts, I'd really appreciate any guidance because I'm not sure where to go from here!


P.S. The only way I can prevent the issue from occurring is to assign Finder to all desktops but I greatly dislike how cluttered this leaves all my desktops (plus this doesn't fix the bug, it just avoids it)


P.P.S There is a similar issue reported here, however, in their case the issue also occurs when they between applications on the same desktop:

Big Sur Finder tab changes when focus ret… - Apple Community



[Re-Titled by Moderator]



MacBook Air, macOS 15.4

Posted on May 21, 2025 12:17 PM

Reply
5 replies

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

How do I prevent Finder tabs from changing when switching desktops in macOS?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.