The situation you’re describing doesn’t sound right at all. Under AppleCare+, your MacBook Pro’s power adapter is covered for defects, at no extra cost, if the adapter is faulty due to a manufacturing issue..However, AppleCare+ doesn’t cover loss, theft, or accidental damage to accessories — in that case, they usually charge for a replacement. The fact that they quoted you more than the actual retail price of the adapter is unusual and suggests a billing or process error on their end.
Here’s what I suggest that you try:
- Visit Apple’s coverage page and confirm that your MacBook Pro is still under AppleCare+ and that the end date hasn’t passed.
- Take photos or videos of your adapter showing it not working, and if there’s visible wear, highlight it.
- When you call Apple Support again, ask for a *senior advisor*. Explain clearly that you have AppleCare+, the adapter is failing, and you are being quoted more than the retail price. Mention that this is your second attempt with no service provided.
- If possible, go in person. They often process warranty claims more smoothly than call-based support.