Magic Mouse right click not working on iMac

Magic Mouse Right Click not working on my iMac but works perfectly on my other mac. I already did everything suggested online like assigning secondary click in system settings and removing the .plists needed to be removed in library preferences including the hidden .Global ones then restarting. Are there other things I can do? I know it's not a device issue as right click works on my macbook. Is there anything else I can do to fix this? Thanks! (iMac M4 OS Tahoe)