The below is from an AI / LMM
If the below works, I take not credit
This is a surprisingly common issue on recent macOS versions (including the macOS Tahoe). The Translate context menu doesn’t always use your “Preferred Languages” list the way you’d expect. It can instead latch onto:
- the last translation target used,
- Siri & Dictation language,
- Apple Intelligence language,
- Safari translation preferences,
- or even a stuck cached language pair.
French showing up by default even when it’s nowhere in your language list usually means the translation service cache got stuck at some point.
Try these fixes in order — the earlier ones are the most likely to solve it.
1. Change the Translate Target Directly (Most Important)
When you:
- Highlight text
- Right-click → Translate
In the translation popup:
- Look for the language dropdown at the top/right.
- Change French to Japanese or English (US) manually once.
Then:
- close the popup completely,
- try translating again.
macOS often remembers the last used translation target, not your system language order.
2. Check Apple Intelligence / Siri Language
On Tahoe, translation is increasingly tied into Apple Intelligence and Siri settings.
Go to:
System Settings → Apple Intelligence & Siri
Check:
- Language
- Preferred Responses Language
- Siri Language
If any of these are French, change them.
Recommended:
- Siri Language → English (Australia) or English (US)
Then reboot.
3. Remove French from Translation Downloads
macOS sometimes keeps offline translation packs.
Go to:
System Settings → General → Language & Region
Then:
- look for Translation Languages
- or Live Translation
- or Downloaded Languages (wording changes between builds)
If French is installed:
- remove it,
- restart,
- then install Japanese instead.
4. Reset the Translation Cache (Very Effective)
This is often what actually fixes the “always French” bug.
Open:
Run:
defaults delete com.apple.Translate
Then reboot your Mac.
If that says the domain doesn’t exist, try:
defaults delete com.apple.translationd
Then reboot again.
This resets saved translation preferences and cached target languages.
5. Check Safari Translation Preferences
Even if you’re translating outside Safari, macOS sometimes inherits Safari translation defaults.
Open:
Then:
- Safari → Settings → Languages
- Remove French if present.
- Make sure English/Japanese are prioritized.
6. Force-Reorder Preferred Languages
Even though you already checked this, try:
- Remove ALL extra languages temporarily
- Leave only:
- Restart Mac
- Test Translate
- Add the others back later
Tahoe betas especially have bugs where hidden language priorities survive normal changes.
7. If You’re on a Tahoe
macOS Tahoe, this is very likely a bug rather than misconfiguration. There are reports of:
- Translate ignoring preferred language order
- French/German sticking as target languages
- Translation language not persisting
Updating to the newest beta patch often fixes it.
Check:
- System Settings → General → Software Update
What Usually Works
In practice, the fixes that most often solve this are:
- Manually changing the language once inside the Translate popup
- Resetting translation defaults via Terminal
- Changing Siri/Apple Intelligence language
- Rebooting after removing French translation packs
If you want, I can also show you:
- how to completely reset macOS language services,
- how to make Japanese the primary translation target specifically,
- or how to disable automatic language detection entirely.