sambland109 wrote: …my equally elderly 1TB external drive has decided to stop working too! Which now makes me a little nervous about relying on external drives for long-term backups... While £2.99 a month for iCloud storage isn't a fortune, I think it's my only option.
I've had several hard drives go "dead parrot" on me, and the lesson is that we can't rely on a single hard drive, or even just one form of backup. Everything at iCloud should be backed up to a hard drive, and vice versa.
iCloud is a limited sort of backup, since, as a mirror of our Macs, we can't really go back to before we made mistakes. A Time Machine drive is the way to help with that. But iCloud serves as non-local storage incase of disaster.
In addition, I have separate Archive backups that I only use periodically. They are 10 TB 3.5 inch spinning drives, old, slow, but different from the other backups.
So I've decided that one hard drive just isn't enough. Unfortunately, they've gotten rather more expensive in the last couple of years.