Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Controlling the fan in MacbookPro 13”-any practical tips about it, please?

I need to find out are there any useful ways to control cooling of my MacBook, perhaps by setting the way the fan works because there is information that cooling fans of MacBooks are not doing very good job…

I’ve found that there are some programs that can do it such as Fan Control but it says that if I uninstall it I have to Reset the System Management Controller (SMC) and I am not sure if it’s a good idea to tweak with SMC - I’m not very techno proficient…

The question- how to improve the cooling by setting up the fan in a safe enough way- I don’t want to cause any accidental damages…
The MacBookPro 13” is built in 2010, has chip Intel Core 2 Duo 2.4 GHz, and OSX 10.6.4
It works ok, sometimes gets quite hot,80-95 degrees Celsius and I have Temperature Monitor program which shows what is the current temperature of CPU, core1 and core2.

Any practical advise about what I should do, by people who are familiar with this fan & cooling issue, please?

mac book, Mac OS X (10.6.4)

Posted on Sep 13, 2010 10:13 PM

Reply
19 replies

Sep 14, 2010 2:58 AM in response to oliviaps

"...because there is information that cooling fans of MacBooks are not doing very good job…"

I don't know where you get your info from. However, the best place to discuss this would be the MacBook Pro hardware forums:
http://discussions.apple.com/category.jspa?categoryID=251
in as much as this really has little to do with Mac OS X v10.6 Snow Leopard > Installation and Setup.

Sep 14, 2010 8:11 AM in response to oliviaps

First off I recommend not to fiddle around with the smc fan data .. It can go wrong but the solution is simpler than you imagine .. you jjst reset the smc and it's all fine .. If you feel you must go ahead then you can use smc fan control or istats menu that will sort you out ..
I myself use a product called zephyr from moshi .. which keeps my machine cool by looking hot 😉

Sep 14, 2010 9:36 AM in response to oliviaps

I get a chuckle, Apple waits for the temps to get way too warm, and then the fans kick in; that is how it "works" on Mac Pro and it is terrible way to go about cooling. So 90% do use the SmcFanControl 2.x that works fine for Mac Pro - and no SMC reset ever needed.

I've been using that for almost 4 yrs.

Macs do get too warm, and Core i processors have pushed the limits. Heat is hard on components which is why part failures and replacements for laptops are higher than desktops.

Hardware Monitor and Temperature Monitor Updates for 2010 Mac Pro and iMacs
http://www.bresink.de/osx/HardwareMonitor.html

Do you think your MacBook (Pro) is running to hot?
Give Fan Control a try then.

Some MacBook (Pro) are just to hot for daylong use. Fan Control adjusts the minimum fan speed depending on the current CPU temperature. For safety, it leaves the original automatic fan speed control intact.


My guess is that 10,000s of users have downloaded and run FanControl.
All it is doing is loading a new set of numbers, it is not touching (and can't) the System Management Unit.

Windows on Macs is even a worse issue when it comes to thermal sensors and fan control (almost zilch).

People have sat through 5 generations of Mac Pros and fan control is high on the wish list, but hasn't budged, it is easier to keep air and fans cooling (and use a couple profiles) rather than try to expel hot air afterwards. For Mac Pro all it takes is a small 300 to 400 boost in minimal fan speed to make a big difference.

Sep 18, 2010 11:53 PM in response to oliviaps

Well, guys I've got SMC Fan Control and set it to work

Setting - speed 2500 rpm ( about 500 rpm above the default setting) and right now it shows the temperature 41 degrees Celsius.

HOWEVER, I have Temperature Monitor which displays following readings of 3 of computer sensors:
for CPU diode sensors = 44 degrees Celsius
for core 1 sensor = 46 degrees Celsius
for core 2 sensor = 41 degrees Celsius

Both programs read temperature at the same time but still there is this difference in displayed data.

Why is it and which data should be trusted??????

And another thing - does anyone know how SMC Fan Control measures the temperature?

Thanks for any competent replies!
Ema

Sep 19, 2010 8:41 AM in response to oliviaps

emaema wrote:
And another thing - does anyone know how SMC Fan Control measures the temperature?


There are thermal diodes in and around the cpu , gpu , harddisk , rams etc all around the machine ..
It just gets the readings from them ..

istats menu can read every single sensor on your machine and therefore can give a broader understanding of the temperature situation and why-how it's rising up ..

it also has the same functionality as smc fan control ..actually you can define presets of fan speed etc ..

I want to mention one more time that I think playing with your fan speeds is not only unnecessary but also dangerous 🙂

good luck

Controlling the fan in MacbookPro 13”-any practical tips about it, please?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.