4298 Views Previous 1 2 Next 20 Replies Latest reply: Nov 11, 2010 7:28 AM by Frank Caggiano Go to original post
I fall into what you described as example #2. This is the only time I seem to run into this issue. It is when I set the camera to the local time, shoot in that local time and then import in a different time zone (home). When I do this, I do the steps exactly as you logically outlined them. I set the time zone settings so that both the camera time and the actual time are the same and match the actual shoot time.
This being said, my issue isn't that the image doesn't show the proper time, date and time zone in Aperture. I can see this info in the Metadata Pane and it is correct. The issue I'm gVing arises when I try to export the image. If I export the image and set the export settings so that the image is stored in a folder by date, the times are off. Now mind you, I only know that the times are off on images which change date based on a time zone change. For example, an image shot at 10:30 pm PST on 11/9/10 gets placed in a folder named 11/10/10 -the next day. This happens because Apeeture us saying that the original image time is EST, or 1:30 am the next day. The way I confirm this is by going to the image in Aperture. I pull down the "Adjust Date and Time..." menu item and it tells me that the image has a date and time of 1:30 am on 11/10/10, not 10:30 pm on 11/9/10 which would be the correct PST, and the time that shows in my Metadata Pane associated with that image.
I just don't understand why Aperture is keeping track of the image in two different times, and I would like to know how to stop it from doing so.
Dies this make sense?
OK so if understand correctly the problem you're having is actually on export not on import.
It does seem that Aperture is doing some counterintuitive things with dates both in 'Adjust Date and Time' and on export.
From the playing around I've done it appears that Aperture is normalizing the time to the local time zone on export but only of the Subfolder Format section.
So for example if I have an image with the Date & time of 3/23/2010 23:44 PST AND the timezone of the my Mac is set to EST then when I export the image if I select a subfolder format of image year/month/day then the day subfolder is created as 24. However if the time zone of the MAc is set to PST then the day subfolder is created as 23.
Now all this seems to only affect the subfolder times. If I select image date/Time as the name of the image in Name Format it always appears with the correct image date and time. So in this example no matter the Time Zone of the Mac the image name was always 2010-03-23 23-44-21.jpg
This doesn't really help you directly but I guess its good to know you're not nuts (at least in this instance )
As for Adjust Date and Time it to seems to normalizing for the time zone. Change the time zone of the Mac and the time in Adjust Date and Time changes also.
Not sure how this behavior compares to other image management software, I certainly wouldn't do it this way or at least I'd make it configurable, but perhaps for Pros that really travel around a lot it makes sense.
Hope this helps, somewhat.
You are spot on in your analysis. While true this doesn't help me directly, it at least let's me know that I'm not crazy, and that I wasn't doing anything wrong. I guess I just won't use the Image Day/Month/Year subfolder format when I export images. It is a shame to have options (and Aperture gives you plenty throughout the application), but to not be able to use them because they don't work correctly, nor universally. The only way that they would work correctly would be if you went through the steps of importing like we've outlined, and then exported the images from Aperture while you were still in the field (thus still in the time zone which you shot the images in). Of course, I guess you could also change the time zone settings in your preferences so that they don't update automatically, but that is silly.
I am going to avoid using that subfolder format for now. I may use image date (this being different than image month/day/year). For some reason, when you use image date as a whole, it places it into a subfolder with the correct date. When you export it with a subfolder format of image month/day/year, the day is off based on the time of day the image was shot. This type of thing seems like a bug. As far as I am concerned, if you import the image with certain time and date metadata, that information should be stored and be usable upon export.
As for the "Adjust Time and Date..." function, the only way to use it seems to be to use it before setting/correcting any time zone issues. If for some reason the time on your camera was off (not due to Time Zone, but rather off by minutes, etc...) you can correct the time using that function, and then correct the time zone using the batch change function afterwards. The "Adjust TIme and Date..." feature is really only for date issues and incremental changes to the time, not due to time zone inaccuracies.
Perhaps Apple designed this to work best for professionals in the field. I am anal, especially when it comes to information that is categorical and archival. I want it to be accurate. Maybe Apple needs to design this aspect of the app so that it works properly under all situations, not just those it perceives to be most useful to professionals. As you said, they should at least make this a configurable option.
Anyway, thanks for the input, and the time you've spent helping me to think this through. It was extremely helpful.
Message was edited by: macorin
It looks like this thread could be finished and I wanted to make sure you had a solution. I think your solution is on two fronts:
1) when you first import your images, you need to make sure you set the time zone settings correctly. Since you have been following this thread, you should have some idea of what I am talking about. First off, hopefully you are setting your camera time to PST. Even if you aren't though, you can correct that with the Time Zone settings during import. As has been discussed, you simply set the "Camera Time" and "Actual Time" to PST and your images will show up with the PST label that you are looking for. If you didn't set your camera time to PST, you set the "Camera Time" to EST and the "Actual Time" to PST and the adjustment will be made and the label of PST will show correctly.
2) as for the images you have already imported, the "Adjust Date and Time..." is the wrong place to make the adjustment you are looking for. This will adjust the date, and also the time by any increment you want, but will leave the time zone the same. You need to go to the "Batch Change" function. You want the batch change function anyway, because you are going to be changing multiple images. Click on all of the images you want to change, and then within the batch change function, you will select the adjust time zone feature. Now you can proceed to set the "Camera Time" and "Actual Time" just as you would have done at import.
Note: if the time of day or date is wrong because you simply weren't paying attention to the clock on your camera, I would first change that with the "Adjust Date and Time..." function, and then proceed to change the time zone with batch change.
I hope this helps, makes sense and is what you were looking for.
I appreciate you making sure I understood the solution to my problem. Your explanation solved the problem I've had with the time zones. Been making several mistakes, with the first mistake that I often forget to reset the local time when I get in the PST zone. I then adjusted the time (EST) I have set in the camera in Aperture using the "Adjust Time and Date". I followed your explanation and sure enough using the "Batch Change" solved the problem.
I initially thought my problem was the same as yours, but I can now see where I did not understand fully. Your reply made 100% sense and was exactly what I needed to understand. Thanks again for your help.