Lawrence, I take your points, but I don't really think those are apt analogies.
First off, it was NOT a hack to bypass TouchID (which would give access to the entire phone) or to get into a bank account (which would give unfettered access to someone's money.) It was a hack which only helps a person who has an unlocked iPhone to which they already have the passcode—presumably a trusted user. There is no way to make the steps work without creating a backup, and no way to create a backup without the passcode.
I would add that if I forget my lock screen passcode, or my TouchID is wiped out, I can restore the phone and create a new one! If I forget my bank account PIN I can reset it or walk into the bank and show my ID. The fact that there is no way for a legitimate user to reset the Restrictions Passcode on the phone is a major, MAJOR flaw. Wiping the phone and rebuilding it is not a viable answer for many folks due to data loss.
Would I care if my kid had found this thread? Not really. If a kid can find this thread, s/he can find the dozens of unauthorized threads around the web devoted to this topic. I'd rather trust my kid and track the spending and if s/he overwrites the restrictions passcode, I would obviously know pretty quickly based on sudden unexpected purchases. And I'd rather this thread have answers that the Apple support community can rely on based on other registered users having tried them rather than asking dedicated Apple fans to sniff around who-knows-what-lurks-there websites around the web.
FWIW, the "next version of iOS" has not blocked this technique. My steps were based on a thread from two years ago when iOS 8 was current. (I cited that post in my response and did nobody any favors as mods have now chased the post down and deleted it after it sat there for two years). Also, please don't tell me how this will alert Apple to some features to add in the future. The thread is into its 7th year, and so fixing this major bug is clearly not a priority for them.
Lastly: I didn't violate any community guidelines. The relevant section is here:
- No material may be submitted that is intended to promote or commit an illegal act.
- Do not submit software or descriptions of processes that break or otherwise 'work around' digital rights management software or hardware. This includes conversations about 'ripping' DVDs or working around FairPlay software used on the iTunes Store.
Nothing I posted was a violation of either of those. (Although this post is a violation, as it is no longer a reply to the original topic! 😉 )
With all respect to you Lawrence, this is the last I will post on the matter. I'm frustrated because composing the original post took over an hour, and the findings within were the result of several hours of difficult work on my behalf, saving my friend from having to wipe her phone and lose a ton of data. I felt heroic when I was able to help her out, and wanted to pass the karma forward to others. I read the guidelines and the entire thread before I posted and felt I was in compliance. I understand the predicament Apple is in, but since the " Views expressed on the [Community] Site are not endorsed by Apple," I think they are pretty well covered.
Cheers.