You can make a difference in the Apple Support Community!

When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Voice memo time limit?

Is there a time limit to the length of recordings using Voice Memo?
thanks
Pete

iPhone 4 IOS 4.2.1

Mac Book Pro 17" / QS G4 867 / iPhone 4, Mac OS X (10.6.5)

Posted on Dec 30, 2010 1:46 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Dec 30, 2010 2:03 PM

I believe iOS 4.0 removed the limit, which was somewhere around ~33 minutes or so. I believe it was limited by file size more than recording length and thus would vary from about 30 minutes to around 37 minutes max. I know you can go to at least two hours now, but I have not tested recently since iOS 4.2.1.
26 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Dec 30, 2010 2:03 PM in response to Peter Whitaker

I believe iOS 4.0 removed the limit, which was somewhere around ~33 minutes or so. I believe it was limited by file size more than recording length and thus would vary from about 30 minutes to around 37 minutes max. I know you can go to at least two hours now, but I have not tested recently since iOS 4.2.1.

Jan 4, 2011 5:47 AM in response to paulcb

I made some tests and found, that the bug is caused not by record length only, but two circumstances together: record length and the way a record is stopped.
If a 2 h record is stopped with the stop key and I waited the iPhone has done its work after stop, the record can be synced with iTunes correctly.
If a 1 h 24 min record is stopped with incoming call, or the process is stopped with the stop key but Voice Memo application is exited immediately after stop, the record cannot be synced with iTunes, nor played with iPhone.
Anyway, slider does not work when a long record is played.
A short record can be synced with iTunes and played with iPhone correctly regardless of the way the record is stopped.
Is this bug inherent to iPhone 4g?

Thanks in advance for your reply.

Feb 19, 2011 6:52 AM in response to Yelisey

I've noticed the same.

Some long voice memos not playing on the iPhone (slider not moving)
and
These same long voice memos not synching with iTunes so can't be played there either.

I've noticed too that these long voice memos are the ones where I pressed the voice memo on screen stop button, and then the main iPhone stop button quickly straight afterwards and thus not giving enough time for the iPhone to finish thinking (and it might be that longer voice memos require a longer think time after stopping recording that shorter voice memos).

There is no problem with short voice memos. I can stop recording and then abrupty press the main iPhone stop button afterwards and nothing is lost. Presumably this is because the phone doesn't need so much time to think and register properly what it's just recording.

So beware people who want to record long lectures. When you press the on screen stop button to stop recording, allow the phone to think for a bit while still in voice memo app. Don't press the main iPhone button to exit the voice memo app too soon.

QUESTIONS:
(1) Does anyone know if it is possibele to recover these long voice memos despite this?
(2) Can we see if they are taking up memory on the phone?

If so, then there might be something to salvage, but I guess it would have to be salvaged from the phone, given that it's not syncing with the computer.

Jun 16, 2011 2:55 PM in response to Peter Whitaker

Agree to yelsiler.

U have to give enough time to ur phone to save the long memos. I recorded 2:29 hrs long, it played fine.

Today I recorded 2:59hrs, but stupidity I did, I stopes memo and immediately quit the voice memo app. That made file corrupt.

I think better to make many files each 2 hrs, for short save time for phone and without risk, I regret for what I lost very important lecture today.

Even iPhone explorer can't help in corrupted files situation.


I hope in future, no one would make this mistake.

Jul 7, 2011 10:35 AM in response to Peter Whitaker

I've recorded successfully (albeit accidentally) for 9 1/2 hours (267.1mb file) that was recognized by both iTunes and Voice Memos. I more typically record for 1-3 hours and it all works great.


However, two days ago my recordings just started stopping after 17mins 5secs over and over again. I'm wondering if anyone has had similar problems and what the potential fix might be? Thanks

Sep 8, 2011 7:15 AM in response to Bethabike

I am using Apple iPhone 3G. I used my iPhone to record a meeting this afternoon. The apps which I used was voice memo. The recording was about 1hr and 39 mins. After the meeting finished, I pressed the paused button and then touched the stop button. Unfortunately, the voice memo quit without warning. I started the app again, but it just could not play the recording.


Fortunately, I connected it to my ubuntu and I discovered that there were two files created. One was 20110908 XXXXX.m4a, which was corrupted. The other file was 20110908 XXXXX.mov, which could only played for 12 seconds. I then converted the file to mp3 format by using FFMPEG. To my surprise, this free tool recovered my full length recording.


One last mystery remains is the cause of this wierd bug. Can anyone figure it out?

Sep 8, 2011 9:00 AM in response to jim hong kong

This bug is indeed a mystery, and it's not entirely reliable, but it seems that Itunes 3G creates a .mov file when the recording is over a certain time limit wrong, and this is the only file -- not the mp3 file -- which will play when extracted from the phone and transfered manually to itunes.


I was having a double nightmare, though, because I recorded a 1 hr 40 minute interview, and couldn't get it off -- because the iphone hadn't created a .mov file of it. What I finally was able to do, and which did work, was go into voice memos, and after selecting the memo, I pushed Trim Memo and shaved the first 15 seconds and the last 15 seconds off the interview and resaved it.


Then, the resulting new, "trimmed" MP3 file which showed up in Phone Disk (which is the highly recommended for-pay version of iphone explorer, since it allows you to use the iphone as a hard disk) was not corrupted and transferred to Itunes without a problem.


Intererestingly, this technique -- trimming the memo -- was advocated on another thread as a way of getting a VM to download merely through synching, but I've tried that both with and without success, so there's no hard and fast rule here.


And for the record, I have recorded 5+ hours on the iphone and gotten them off no problem. So there's no time limit per se.

Mar 27, 2012 4:27 AM in response to Peter Whitaker

i have a question not an answer unfortunately. i just installed lion to find it does not support olympus ds330. so i dictated to iphone for the first time for 34 mins. after nine mins i paused and came back two hours later. the iphone says it is 34 mins long; it synced with itunes where it says it is 9 mins long. the audio stops at 9 mins on the iphone despite the info saying it is 34 mins long. does anyone know what is going on? any ideas as to how i can recover the other 25 mins? any thoughts much appreciated. thanks.

Mar 27, 2012 8:01 AM in response to JP9994

You have one of the more advanced problems with this bug. I would get iExplorer and just follow the steps there to retrieve your file from the media/recordings folder. That is a great program, and totally necessary if you want to continue to use this app. I use it on a weekly basis, and it's great to know that if nothing else works you have a safety net.


I would also make sure you have any recordings you want from your phone, and then do a full-on backup and restore the phone. It was only after I restored the phone that I stopped having so many problems with this. I still have some, mind you, just not so many.


I would also not ever use 'pause.' I would just stop and start again. Playing with fire. This app is basically a beta version -- don't mess around with it like it's a real app.

Voice memo time limit?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.