So when I try to crop the 12x2 image to 4x6 it clips the ends and does not 'shrink' the photo.
that is correct - cropping cuts off part of the photo - which is why I did suggest cropping
in the preview window on the customize screen right click on the photo and select *"fit photo to frame size"* - this will display the entire photos with white space fill to fill out the paper size and *eliminate cropping*
Also, when I try to 'fit to paper'
I'm not sure what you are doing - if you follow my instruction and in the customize preview window right click and select "fit photo to frame size" you fill the frame with white space so the whole photo is displayed and will be printed - if this is not happening for you renew your iPhoto preference file - A good general step for strange issues is to renew the iPhoto preference file - quit iPhoto and go to "your user name" ==> library ==> preferences ==> com.apple.iPhoto.plist and trash it - launch iPhoto which creates a fresh new default preference file and reset any personal preferences you have changed and if you have moved the iPhoto library repoint to it. This may help
This does not affect your photos or any database information (keywords, faces, places, ratings, etc) in any way - they are stored in the iPhoto library - the iPhoto preference file simply controls how iPhoto works - which is why renewing it is a good first step.
it fills with no white space. Have you both tested these solutions? I will attempt your solutions again incase I missed something.
Yes I have tested it with iPhoto '08, '09 and '11 - it works the same in all three versions exactly as I described it
LN