MickCharles wrote:
It is supposed to function as i described (true/false?)
False, per the link provided above:
"If you download a rented movie on your iPhone 4 or later, iPad, iPod touch (4th generation or later), or Apple TV: It is not transferable to any other device or computer." The only way to transfer a rented movie is if you rent it from your computer, and then it can be moved around to other devices but (a) it can only exist on one device at a time, and (b) you cannot move it to Apple TV 2 or 3. It is odd that you can't do what you want, but I'm not a lawyer ;)
MickCharles wrote:
i'm renting SD movies from iT so copyright issues are in the full control of AAPL on all AAPL devices
I don't know the legal agreements between Apple and movie studios, but with a rental you don't own the material so I suspect that is the difference. With a purchase you're given some leeway that you don't have with a rental.
MickCharles wrote:
It has functioned as described; rented iT movies on iP and played through ATV to Video Monitor on many occasions in the past - as recent as 8 days ago.
Your original post mentioned that purchases worked, not rentals. Have you ever seen a rental stream from your i-device to Apple TV? I wouldn't think so, given Apple's statement above.
MickCharles wrote:
All other streaming functions from iP and iPh to ATV; music, photos, and home-made video function
These would not be subject to the same copyright issues as a movie.
You can try taking this up with Apple, and depending on who you communicate with (and your approach) may determine your success to get a refund. Apple does state that you can't stream a movie from your device to ATV, but perhaps not clearly enough (which you might use to your advantage).