246929 Views Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 … Next 962 Replies Latest reply: Sep 15, 2014 6:52 AM by miroslavfromprague 9 Go to original post
New 2011 15" Macbook Pro, last week.
Trouble since the first night I got it home, connecting to any wifi network (both in OS X and Win7). Have tried everything I can find, removed all keychains (this doesn't affect Windows), have reset the PRAM and SMC. Changed and tried all number of settings on my router (I don't even see why I SHOULD have to do this). Still having trouble, no other machines or devices I have get any trouble connecting to my network, or the networks around here.
Only this machine. Sometimes it does work, but not for long, the connection will drop and won't re-connect. As far as I am concerned (I'm a technical engineer at an IT support company, I pretty much know what I'm doing), its either a hardware or firmware fault with the WiFi card. Now, this is the first Macbook Pro I have owned, so I'm just looking for a bit of guidance.
Return to the Apple store for a replacement? Wait for a firmware update? I understand that the WiFi card is proprietary ( Broadcom BCM4331 ), is it replaceable with another vendor? Will the Apple store just provide me with a new card, and I can swap that in-store?
Unsure what I should do, this is the only problem I have with this machine.
Turn up airport debugging on the MacBookPro the next time you cannot connect to a WiFi hotspot. Most hotspots run with OPEN+NO encryption with a Web portal Authentication/Backend, so really I would be surprised if your MBP cannot connect to that type of network.
Anyway, to turn up airport logging in Snow Leopard open a terminal and issue the following command:
sudo /usr/libexec/airportd debug +AllUserland +AllDriver +AllVendor
Note the time, then reproduce the issue.
Go to the kernel.log and post the entries from about 2 minutes before you reproduced the issue to about 2 minutes after.
To get to your kernel.log you can use the console app in utilities. Look in /var/log
To turn off airport logging issue the following in a terminal window:
sudo /usr/libexec/airportd debug -AllUserland -AllDriver -AllVendor
Lets start with that and see what we can see.
Any instructions for debugging the issue for Windows 7 ?
... the service center ran diagnostics on the MBP twice and told me everything is working ... and I know ppl with this issue have contacted an authorized service center and / or a genius and were told that its working ... there are several posts with the logs posted and latency tests (ping delays) posted everywhere, refer to this thread for pings and other details on the issue, there are other threads also:
Message was edited by: Noman84
No news from my side, but I am very glad to know in the meantime ( alone 48 posts here in my thread about a wlan issue on the new Macbook pro 2011!)that I am not the only one and that I am not just too stupid to connect a Macbook to the network...where all our other divices are running without any problems.
Still same issue! Macbook has got trouble with the weak net. I think, the reason why there are not many more complains might be, that the problem is not occuring when you have got a very strong net. I did not have any trouble at all at home in Germany sitting nearly beside of our router with a full blast of a 32 MB Wlan connection.
Here in our hotel wlan the conection is much slower and weaker. BUT as I said, the other devices as four different Windows Mashines, my Ipad and Iphone and the HTC of my husband are able to connect on that net without trouble. Its slow and weak but it works for the other ones. Only my Macbook gets thrown out frequently. I have to restart the wireless adapter to get a connection from time to time, than it works for a while and than its gone again.... Very very unsatisfieng with a brandnew notebook. I will try if I can get the update working now...but I have my doubts...on this connction level at present, downloading anything is a mission impossible.
I found something.
Kernel log extract:
Mar 24 09:32:25 MacBook-kernel: wl0: Beacon Loss Event
Mar 24 09:32:25 MacBook-kernel: AirPort: Link Down on en1. Reason 4 (Disassociated due to inactivity).
Since I have seen this, I am connected with some artificial traffic and no more suddenly connection drops (for 20 minutes at least).
Maybe is a power management bug :S
There is another mensage that concern me at Airport switch on:
Mar 24 09:26:01 MacBook-Pro-de-Diego-M kernel: en1: setting diversity to: -1
Mar 24 09:26:01 MacBook-Pro-de-Diego-M kernel: en1: Error configuring antenna diversity (index = -1).
Mar 24 09:26:01 MacBook-Pro-de-Diego-M kernel: en1: setting tx antenna: -1
Mar 24 09:26:01 MacBook-Pro-de-Diego-M kernel: en1: Error configuring transmit antenna (index = -1).
Could be another bug?
I'm also suffering from this issue. Initially I had a lot of disconnections and low speed, but after I changed the channel in the router configuration, the disconnections are now rare. The connection speed however, it's slow (200Kb/s) but a least I can surf the web. I'm going to try linux on the machine to see if is a hardware problem or an driver issue.
What wireless router are you using and are you seeing these drops frequently ?
Everyone who complains here needs to at the very minimum, post their Wireless Router make and firmware version's so if there is a trend with a particular make/model it's easy to figure out.
Have you also tried changing channels and using a less congested channel ? Have you checked if your router is running the latest firmware version ?
I am running on an Airport Extreme Base Station that has worked flawlessly for a year. I had an early 2008 Black Macbook that I sold to buy this new Early 2011 Macbook Pro and it never dropped its wifi connection ever.
Taking Macbook Pro to Apple Store tonight, Im sure they won't be able to reproduce the issue.
Everything else ... even 4-5 year old laptops connect just fine ... IMHO i do not think this can be a router issue. Also, how do you go about determining which router / firmware they have at the hotel / restaurant you want to connect to WiFi on ? ... also, when you connect an external USB Wifi device to the MBP it connects to the same network (and the same router) just fine.
Even older Macbooks with the latest version of OS X connect without any issues and MBP 2011 refuses to connect or drops out.
Trying to connect on Windows 7 is even worse, its probably a hardware / driver / positioning of the NIC issue. The issue happens for open / unsecured / unencrypted networks as well.
The Wireless card by Broadcom that is used in the new MBPs is relatively new and possibly not well tested, I can only hope its only a driver issue and not a hardware / device issue.
Im starting to think that it is a hardware issues. Also its posible that its a bad batch of cards. I wonder if there are people who dont have issues, but its hard to access as they wouldnt come here. Also since it is an issues randomly people might not notice right away. If it is just an issue with card they can replafe the card i guess.