Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Processor upgrade 1.1 macpro. is it worth it?

HI

I have a mac pro v.1.1 (2006) with 2x 2ghz core duo (intel 5130) 8gb ram, 4tb HDD.
Past year Mac pro started to be slow, It take too much time to render video, browse Safari, etc, I tried to reinstall Snow leopard and I guess this machine is getting old and Im getting often annoyed, my new macbook pro is faster then this.

Right now I'm thinking to boost the processor speed. On ebay I find good deal for 2x 2.66ghz quad core Intel 5355.

But my question is, is it worth it to upgrade? in comparison 5130 vs 5355? and in 5355 and recent version of quad core?

thanks for help?

Macbook Pro 2ghz, Apple MacPro 2x2.0 GHz Dual Core Xeon, 8 GB RAM, 1.250 TB HD, Mac OS X (10.5.5), 1TB Time capsule, 2TB external HDD,

Posted on Apr 8, 2011 3:25 AM

Reply
154 replies

Apr 28, 2011 9:45 PM in response to DonH49

The comparison does not list the X5355 2.66GHz processors. Have a look at this link which shows a 2.66GHz Dual fitted with the X5355 processors, a jump from 4952/9436, a 92% increase:-


http://www.waitingoutside.com/2010/02/mac-pro-upgraded-with-2-intel-xeon-x5355-p rocessors/


I guess the bottom line is how much you have to pay for the CPU's. Fitted a pair of X5355 to my Mac Pro 1.1 2.66GHz and the jump is of course tremendous. Like you my machine originally had the 2GHz processors and I went to 2.66GHz Dual and then to the Quads. I did it myself, but depends how comfortable you feel delving inside your Mac Pro. In short, removed hard drives, graphics card, memory riser and removed four screws from memory cage to loosen the cage, jigged the heat sink covers to remove, undo one screw and prize front fan with the assistance of a narrow tool, or a cover from the PCI-E section.


Whilst apart clean the fan and front cheese grater inlet.


Top remove heat sinks really need a size 15 Torx driver. Purchased one from the States for $10, and it is 18" long and handcled the job no trouble. removed heat sinks and original processors. Cleaned up new processors with an alcohol swab wipe, applied Arctive Silver to the CPU, replaced heat sinks and reverse of dismantling. About an hour's work and if had to pay, about the $100.00, but if you are going to get it done, get a quote first.


The only problem, if it could be called that, is Apple System profiler in About this Mac describes the Processor as 2.66GHz Unknown. The hardware Overview shows eveything correct, 8 cores, 2 Processors each with 8MB of L2 cache.


Purchased my X5355 from eBay Australia for $351.00 the paid which I considered worth the price, but that is up to the individual.


Anyone help with changing Apple System Profiler About this Mac to change Unknown to Intel Xeon Quad Core?

Apr 30, 2011 3:03 PM in response to romko23

You did get the one mentioned, romko23, from mediafire?


Found at least two when Googled. Appeared on the desktop as a software inastall package, ran in about five seconds and up came About this Mac similar to Der Det, except of courtse reporting X5355 processors. Maybe it works on Mac Pro 1.1 and 2.1 only?

Apr 30, 2011 4:35 PM in response to Benjamin Kier

Yes Benjamin the X5355 2.66GHz and X5365 3GHz CPU's will both work in your Mac Pro 1.1.


You will see there are various step numbers, SL9R6, SLAEG etc, they are not important. What is important is you need a pair of processors, and preferably a matched pair at that. Matched pairs have identical serial numbers. The seller you listed offers only the one single CPU.


This comes about because some Dell and HP machines use a single processor. All the X5355/5365 are interchgangable as all are Intel Xeons.

Apr 30, 2011 4:40 PM in response to harryb

why wont it work if the serial numbers aren't matched? also, is their a way to supplment the mac pros existing cooling system easily with out making it blast the fans as to keep it quiet?

also, would these listings be the right ones?

http://cgi.ebay.com/Pair-Intel-Xeon-X5355-2-66GHz-Quad-Core-SLAEG-/360358983569? pt=COMP_EN_Networking_Components&hash=item53e711b791#ht_958wt_1015


and


http://cgi.ebay.com/2x-Intel-Xeon-X5365-Server-CPU-8-CORES-MATCHED-PAIR-/2207753 95660?pt=CPUs&hash=item33673d314c#ht_500wt_898

Apr 30, 2011 4:41 PM in response to Benjamin Kier

Did not say it would not work - said preferably and you will know they are then identical.


For my Mac Pro 1.1, additional cooling not required, smcFanControl currently shows CPUs running at 34 degress C with main fan at 499rpm. Have not seen any temperature increase at all updating from X5130 to X5365. Suggest you download smcFanControl and install it and it will allow you to change the CPU, PCI-E, HDD, Power Supply and Rear Fan speeds.

Apr 30, 2011 5:20 PM in response to harryb

Yes they will both work.


Suggest going for the X5355 as for the 10% increase in the 3GHz model, just not worth all the extra. If you Google 'Updating Mac Pro 1.1' you will find many sites offering instructions. See my earlier post particulalrly about having the at least 10" long Torx 15 driver. The heat sink screws are difficult, if not impossible, to remove otherwise.

May 26, 2011 6:32 AM in response to mikecorp

I had luck, I won auction and purchased 2x 2.66 quad 5355's I paid 285 including shipping. Processors are on the way. Will try to replace them myself. Wish me luck.


I saw people sell raid cards on ebay.


- how much it speeds up computer?


Right now I have 4x 1TB Samsung HDD.

1 osx, 2+3 Raid 0 (using apple soft) used as scratch disk for cs5, and FCP data, 4 Bootcamp.


I was thinking to change HDD 1,2,3 into raid 5 if I would get raid card. Does it make sense? What are yours configurations?

May 26, 2011 2:41 PM in response to The hatter

Can't help with Raid ~ the hatter may be able to help. Use SSD hard drive so don't worry about it. Not into music or photos so do not need so much drive space.


The hardest part of changing the processors is removing the Torx screws which are beneath those huge heatsinks, and if possible get that 8-10" driver first. See my earlier post on changing over. After install suggest downloading and using smcFanControl with which you can increase speed of CPU, PCI-E and hard drive and rear fans.


With the X5355 all ranges of temperatures seem well within normal ~ CPU 26ºC, HDD 17ºC, PCI-E expansion slots 27º. Good luck and keep us posted mikecorp!

Processor upgrade 1.1 macpro. is it worth it?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.