I'm not sure how you can say that iTunes only permits one backup when 4 are currently listed in her iTunes. The problem may arise out of the complicated issue of not fixing phones, but selling refurbs on top of insurance already paid. Each phone creates a new...what is it? UDID? That being said, it becomes very confusing for me to figure out which folders should be (manually) deleted with a clear conscience. It's also disappointing that after deleting questionable backups within iTunes (under the preferences/devices tab you mentioned), that iTunes did nothing to the overall size of the backup directory. We deleted 3 backups through iTunes a few days ago and the overall folder size remained at 65GB. I do not want her to lose any important backup data from either of the 2 phones she is currently using, but it seems that I must manually remove folders from that directory through Windows ~ which is why I'm searching, so far unsuccessfully, for help in these forums. If iTunes had warned of insufficient disk space, when she had tried to restore after getting a refurbed phone, at least one of these folders probably wouldn't exist.
I am also of the opinion that any of the 4 backups listed in iTunes are viable. Why did you claim that only the newest is usable? If they match her iOS, for each phone and it's respective backup, I don't see why they wouldn't work.
Even then, it's still a matter of 2 different phones on 2 different versions of iOS. I need specific information about files that identify if the folder is incomplete or unusable. Something, for example, like a missing info.plist file meaning that the folder is useless.
Also, whatever is an "incremental backup"?
and thank you for responding...no one will respond to the query I initiated