6 Replies Latest reply: Jun 26, 2011 10:17 PM by R&B
Dave_E_P Level 1 Level 1 (30 points)

Is it just me or does synchronize clips not work with DSLR footage and a Zoom audio track?

 

We've been using PluralEyes with FCP7 and since there is no plugin for FCPX we'd be forced to use the audio sync in FCPX.   The problem is that asking it to sync a long piece of audio (zoom) with (say) 10 clips from each of 2 cameras (20 clips in all) shot over the length of the single zoom audio results in all 20 clips being stacked on top of each other at the beginning of the timeline and NOT sync'd. 

 

What gives?   I though it was supposed to sync based on audio not time code (they're all 00:00:00:00).

  • tbonetaylor Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    I am having the same issue! I can't get clips from a DSLR to sync with audio from a zoom. Really dissapointed... Does anyone have a solution to this problem? If not, I have to go back to FCP7...

  • davidjtate Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    I would also like to know if anyone has figured this out!

  • PeteReimund Level 1 Level 1 (5 points)

    seems like a bug!

    if you open up your clip in the timeline and than sync your audio to it manually, it will work.

    i hope apple will clean this up in the next update.

     

    i think, if you have footage which is most the same by format and codec, the sync-feature work.

    i did two videos, one with my ipad and one with my isight.

    in final cut pro x i set the audio to mono for both and voila, it worked.

     

    i hope this helped!

  • f8photography Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    I have the exact same problem, all my recent work at 25fps cannot be synced with my Zoom H4n files at all, however, on messing around with the camera(5D or 7D) and zoom, i put it to 24pfs and the zoom to 44.1khz at 24bit, it synced perfectly....great, however, i want to shoot at 25fps....there must be a way?  I even tried to convert the 25fps footage via various softwares to conform to 24fps and sync it that way....no good....doesnt work at all, is FCPX only suited to 24fps or have i missed something?

  • PeteReimund Level 1 Level 1 (5 points)

    All you have to do is waiting for an update that fixes this problem. At the moment you have to sync it manually to keep the 25fps. Send Apple a Feedback on this to keep them remembered.

  • R&B Level 1 Level 1 (135 points)

    So let me get this straight:

     

    You've got one long piece of audio recorded on a Zoom, and it needs to be sync'd to several different video clips recorded on 2 different cameras.

     

    Your problem is that when you sync audio to those video clips, the same Zoom .aif (or .wav) keeps stacking again and again.

     

    I can't solve your problem, but I can offer a workaround that might help.

     

    Since the audio probably has several different starting and stopping points, why not break it into pieces in a third-party audio editor (I use one called Twisted Wave -- yes, at www.twistedwave.com -- great little audio waveform editor for Mac -- and no, I'm not on their payroll, just a loyal customer).  Break the long audio file into shorter files, putting the cut points at the gaps between video takes.

     

    Then sync *a* video clip to *a* piece of audio.  It ought to work.

     

    Wouldn't have the problem if your audio guy just remembered to stop at the end of a video take and then start recording again with each new video take.  You'd already have the audio clips separated just like the video clips are separated and wouldn't need to resort to this.