I'll add my experience.
I got my R4 and started seeing random disconnects within a week. No dead drives. When the R4 was online all the systems checked out OK. The system log never displayed the correct date and time -- always showing the unit powering on in 1970 or so. Sometimes when the R4 went offline I couldn't physically power it off: I had to yank the power plug from the back.
- noticed a pattern; if the R4 was turned off for several hours it would work longer without disconnects. However, once the first disconnect happens it becomes increasing in frequency until it only stays online for 20-30 minutes at a time. Sometimes the unit worked properly up to 15 hours initially, but the disconnects always returned eventually.
- bought a new TB cable. This changed nothing.
- covered by TB cable in tinfoil. This changed nothing.
- Contacted Promise. Got an RMA and they shipped me a brand new chasis. This changed nothing. Initial great experience for 1-2 days, followed by the same disconnect pattern described above.
- Contacted Apple. Got a new Retina Macbook Pro, just in case mine was botched. This changed nothing.
- Further contacted Promise, they asked me to disable the power management with a terminal command, citing that this fixed issues for some users. This changed nothing. Same pattern of 1-2 days operating normally, then the disconnecting pattern as usual.
- Did some more online research.... found this forum 😟 This is where I am now.