Removing between and in and out point in the timeline

I don't usually post on forums but this has got me quite perplexed:


How do you remove a chunk of media between and in and out point in the FCPX timeline?


It's can't be as hard as it seems to do this task that you have to do all the time. I have a 2 hour 3 camera shoot and I want to remove quite a few 2, 3 minute chucks all through the show. I can't find any way to easily remove these chunks. I know there's no real in and out point in the FCPX timeline anymore but there HAS to be some way to easily remove all the video and audio between two points !!!


I feel really dumb! The answer can't be to make a compound clip as that sure is a pain just to remove something from the timeline. And to blade each individual track means I have to blade at least 8 or 12 things just to remove it!


I have to be missing something. Thanks for any input.

Final Cut Pro X

Posted on Aug 6, 2011 5:43 AM

Reply
14 replies

Aug 6, 2011 1:22 PM in response to Tom Wolsky

Thanks Tom.


I'll have between 3 and 6 layers at any point. I've tried command B but the problem with that is it only puts a cut on the primary storyline. It will cut more than that if I select all the layers. By doing that it's like a 5 or 6 step process to delete chunks of media in the timeline. I can't believe there isn't an easier way than that.


But what makes it worse as I have a long piece of audio only media that is for the whole show. Its a connected clip to the primary storyline. when making edits with command B and then deleting what is between the edits this main audio gets deleted from the edit forward. IT's like this audio becomes a connected clip right after the edit when command B is made. it looks connected to the next clip after the command B but it deletes when I delete the chunk between the command B.


This is so silly that I can't easily delete media from the timeline in this way. It's such a simple thing!

Aug 6, 2011 8:04 PM in response to Tom Wolsky

Yes Tom I understand you can do that and that will add the edit where the playhead line is. But as I was saying that's like 5 or 6 steps to do that each time I want to delete a chunck of media in the timeline. And then I lose that audio. I couldn't put the audio in a primary storyline as it came later. I was rough cutting to one of the cameras.


I just cannot belive that deleting a chunk of media in the timeline really isn't easy or simple like it has been. That's not an unusual thing to want to do. I don't know what Apple as thinking with this.

Aug 6, 2011 10:34 PM in response to shootersteve

Shootersteve, from what you've described I personally think you're complicating your situation. You can have clips as primary storyline as well as secondary storyline clips, use the range tool to select any part of those clips and delete.

Let me ask you this, they're all clips to begin with, why not trim them before you put them into the timeline. Also, as Tom has pointed out, the use the blade tool will also complete your task.

Aug 7, 2011 5:35 AM in response to Tom Wolsky

Tom, I understand that FCPX brings new ideas to editing and I'm fine with that. But what I am wanting to do is something that is done all the time while editing. Say you have an interview that has been completed with broll and everything and the client decides there's several sound bites they want cut out along with broll. It should be a very simple thing to just remove those 5 seconds here, 15 seconds there. I'm just blown away how difficult this simple thing is. I see now it works that way, as in it doesn't work to do something so simple. Thanks for trying to help of course.

Aug 7, 2011 5:41 AM in response to MacvideoHD

machdvideo, I couldn't trim the clip before because this is a hour long, 3 camera shoot. we put the whole show in, synced the 3 clips with synchronize clips. that worked well. I cut the whole show with camera audio and then put in the good audio when we got it later. that's 3 cameras (the main camera is in the primary storyline) and one audio clip that is now the main audio.


That's done and now there's pieces of the show to cut out to make it the right time. I know i can have primary and secondary storylines but it's all the same problem. No matter what kind of storyline it is there's no simple was to just select say 15 seconds (like I mentioned in Toms reply) and just delete that out. Had I known such a simple, simple thing isn't easily possible I would have used something else. This isn't uncommon to want to do when you edit, to cut out a chunk of stuff from the timeline!!


Thanks for your responses.

Aug 7, 2011 6:31 AM in response to shootersteve

I do this all the time. I don't see what's so hard. I mark I/O to make a range selection on the A-roll, press delete and all the connected B-roll clips linked to it disappear with it. Sometimes if you have overhanging clips you may have to decide how to deal with it. Sometimes I cut the clip first, but more often than not I remove it and replace it with something else to bridge the jump cut.

Aug 7, 2011 6:41 AM in response to Tom Wolsky

And if you need to cut weird sections in the middle of overlapping clips, I really don't get what's so hard about drag selecting through a bunch of stacked clips and pressing Cmd-B a couple of times. I know you want to put I/O on the timeline ruler, but you can't. You can press Cmd-B on the fly and all the cuts will be executed when you stop playback. Or you can skim to a point and Cmd-B, which is really handy for easy cut points, much better than scrubbing or fiddling arrow keys.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Removing between and in and out point in the timeline

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.