I've read a few times about people with this issue having the problem of devices not showing up in the list and therefor this doesn't work. I've found that if I plug in a device that doesn't show up in the list, then simply exiting Image Capture and relaunching it will cause the device to show up.
Now my issue is that this has gotten rid of most devices causing Image Capture to launch, however occasionally I still get this splash screen that pops up with a few buttons that say "Always use Capture One" "Import" and "Cancel" or something and then there's another check box for importing video also. It's a completely different interface, but when I [command]+[tab] through open windows it says that the splash screen is image capture. Anyone run into this and have a fix?