When is an iMac considered "old"--a candidate for replacement?

I've just experienced a broken-down Superdrive on my iMac, like the previous one, occuring 4 years after purchase. My use of the Superdrive was only for moderate burning of audio CD files in iTunes. This leads me to the question: when is an iMac considered "old" and therefore eligible for replacing with an upgraded version?


I've finally discovered the convenience and effectiveness of an inexpensive external optical drive--the Samsung S084 (33 bucks at Amazon). It seems more reliable, fast and dependable than my not-so-super Superdrive did when it was working! So at least this time I'm not as frazzled and desperate for a repair or new computer.


Looking at the current line-up of iMacs can be a daunting experience. I notice some going for $999, a price that can easily more than double once you start adding the options at Apple Store. But my perception is that my present 4-year-old machine is as fast as lightning (except when the Time-Warner cable is receiving heavy usage on my block). In fact, I sense no greater speed when using my new 11" Mac Air with Lion.


Still, I see reviews of current Apple offerings by users complaining about their "3-year-old iMacs." Mine is 4 years old. Is it considered a dinosaur? What improvements would I likely notice (besides a working Superdrive) if I invested $1000 to $2,500 or more in a current iMac? Since I'm seeing the same 21" machine configured EN3, EN5, EN7, I'm all the more confused. Perhaps the next line-up of iMacs (I've read we're at the mid-way point of the cycle - MacRumors is not recommending purchase yet) will clear up some of the confusion about all of the possiblities and exactly what an owner has a right to expect from each. Does anyone have a sense of the average lifetime of an iMac for "serious" users (primarily writing, internet, audio media--not photography or webcasting) and an opinion about the current line-up of iMacs (best configuration, the advantages compared to my present machine, the argument about when to purchase, whether now or after the next iMac release). I realize that 4 years isn't "new" (at my old school, our Macs were replaced every other year, leading me to believe that computers "age" at least 2-3 times faster than, say, a new automobile), but apart from the dead Superdrive, it doesn't exactly seem that "old" to me. But perhaps without knowing it, I'm sentencing myself to primitive computing compared to the EN7 Thunderbolt, etc., present-day technology. (Unless practical reasons argue for a 27" model, I'm still prone to prefer the 21" one).


Any info, advice appreciated,


Cap

iMac 2.4 GHz Intel, Mac OS X (10.6.8)

Posted on Sep 20, 2011 11:24 AM

Reply
12 replies

Sep 20, 2011 12:26 PM in response to Cap

Great question, IMHO. I think it boils down to what you really want! You sound like you can get by fine technically with what you have. That's one of the "problems" with a Mac in my experience. They last too long. I still have a Blueberry iBook in the closet, a Beige G3 in my garage, and a G5 Power Mac in the original box. They all work fine (the iBook struggles on the Internet). I have 2 MBPs and an i3 iMac now, and each time I have upgraded has been because something pushes me over some invisible threshold and I realize I need/want the new one. A big threshold was going to Intel, and I always want the newest OS (I think that's one of the reasons to have a Mac - new innovative stuff always coming out.) And then of course there's money. I almost always get a refurb and have never once regretted that. One last impetus to buy newer for me is handing stuff down to our grown children.


It's a mixture of what you need and what you just want. My $.02 worth. And you get what you pay for when it comes to people's opinions!

Sep 20, 2011 1:52 PM in response to Cap

If it does what you need as fast as you need, there's no good reason to change. I'm writing this on a 2007 iMac that's never had a hiccup other than the odd problem caused by badly written third-party software; soon sorted of course.


I only parted with my 1999 and 2001 iMacs and 1999 iBook 2 years ago; all three are still going strong with their new owners.


My G5 is still good, but in the spare room waiting for a new owner also.


Until a new model can offer you something you really need without losing something else you need I see no good reason to change.

Sep 21, 2011 8:54 AM in response to noondaywitch

I replaced my 2004 G5 three months ago with a new (mid 2011) 21.5 " iMac, despite the fact that the G5 was still working OK. But what an improvement! Sharper more colourful screen, much faster, much better software, more elegant. If all you do is text work and emails and not much more, a really old Mac will do the job. But if you want to do more, or you want to enjoy the big improvements, even over 4 years, then go for a new one. I'm really glad I changed.

Sep 21, 2011 11:12 AM in response to Cap

Trying to decide to buy a new computer can always be daunting.

You need to ask yourself the following:


1. Does my current computer do everything I want without issue?

2. Is there something that I would really like to do but really can't

because my current computer just doesn't have the horsepower?

Will I do this often, or just occasionally?

3. Can I spent the money on other devices and or software for my

current computer that will make me more productive or enjoyable?

4. Can I come up with a way to get the new computer without getting

the wife irate?


You may suprise yourself and find that a yes to 3 will out weigh a yes

to 2.


As for 4, your on your own, LOL!

Sep 21, 2011 10:15 PM in response to Dave B.

I'm glad to hear I'm not the only one who has a bunch of old Macs piling up--all of them eligible for resuscitation. But every new machine finds me ordering another $25 manual by David Pogue, etc. I think I'll stick with my 4-year-old Mac and the external optical drive. I'm not sure I even want to bother with spending $30 on the Lion download. Or, for that matter, to renew my subscription to 2 Apple magazines. If you're not careful, you get into a zone where you're lving in constant anticipation of the next new thing. Not a good place to be, because you never get there. Something new is always coming down the pike.


Cap

Sep 22, 2011 10:57 AM in response to Cap

CAP, I'd like to add my two cents to this dialog. I had a G4 Desk top which had reached the limit of aps using the Power PC chip. I was vacillating on buying a new iMac when I noticed that the new machines with Lion would not run any program that ran on the PPC computers. The reason being that they no longer run the Rosetta ap. This would mean that most of the Applications I had such as MS Office 2001 and Quicken 2007 wouldn't run on Lion. Quicken users have been complaining about the new Quicken written for the Intel chip and have advised everyone not to upgrade to it. This plus other reasons led me to the following answer. I bought a brand new 27" iMac left over from MacMall with Snow Leopard for $1499 (A machine that cost $2100 when new). The 21" is $1099.


http://www.macmall.com/s?rch&q=iMac%20Snow%20Leopard&removedLicenseFilter=true&i ncludeImage=true


I am very, very happy with the purchase. My new iMac imported and runs every one of my old applications. At 2.93 GHz, i7 Core and 4GB Ram I don't feel as if I gave up anything in buying an older machine.The only thing my iMac doesn't have is the Thunderbolt ports but since as yet there are few periferals that are Thunderbold the Firewire port is fine. I have a Firewire connection to a 500Gb external drive and dedicate it to the new Time Machine back up and it is very impressive.


I hope this helps you and anybody else who is in the same quandary as you are. Make the move. You won't be sorry.


JDB


JDB

Sep 14, 2014 9:33 AM in response to Cap

I'm wondering the same thing. Mine is an "early 2009" with no problems and is doing everything I need. I've just been wondering if it's time to move to a new iMac before something happens to this one. It sounds from the comments like that's not something I need to be overly concerned with? I'd appreciate a reply or two. Thank you.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

When is an iMac considered "old"--a candidate for replacement?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.