AnyboyMac
If the drive is partitioned MBR (Master Boot Record) and the partition being written to is "NTFS", Mac cannot write to it without software that is NOT free.
OSX can read NTFS, but not write it without paid software, because MS has a semi-patent on the format and may one day prevent anyone else even reading it.
Technically anyone could write software, but those who faced MS in court know the eventual result.
But ... back to technical ...
We have not received a response if the drive was previously formatted for Windows, meaning MBR, and NTFS partitions.
Best to leave permissions alone until more is determined, but you may be partly correct IF the drive is already GUID.