Hello Guys,
I have an unlocked 64GB black iPhone 4S purchased in UK on 01st Nov. I have been facing similar problems as noted in this site since my arrival in India on 08th Nov. I tried various sim cards from Idea (normal SIM cut to micro both existing and new replacement card), Vodafone (existing micro sim card), Airtel (new micro sim) with similar results i.e. signal strength is good but after a short while the network is lost although the signal indicator is showing full strength and 3G. At this time, any phone calling in, is unable to connect while the iPhone 4s continues to display full signal strength. At this time it is possible to use the data network on the 4S and thus use safari, but no incoming or outgoing calls. If I continue trying to make outgoing calls, after usually a couple of tries, all signal bars will drop and it goes in search mode and reacquires the signal. If left alone for a few hours then No Service / Invalid SIM etc would pop up. The battery would also drain at a fair clip.
The only thing common to the above cards is that they are all 64 KB cards.
On 19th Nov I purchased a 128 KB bsnl card and cut to micro sim size. The iPhone 4s worked without any problems.
About an hour ago I got an Airtel 128 KB sim card and had this cut to micro sim. It is about 3 hours now with the Airtel card and the phone is working normally. I will be watching this carefully but am convinced it is the sim card <128 KB that has been the issue with my iPhone 4s. The visible difference between the 64 and 128 kb card is that in case of the 128 KB, the circuit board (gold contact area) extends to the edges on 3 sides with almost less than 1 mm of the plastic on the edges and on the 64 KB it extends to the edge on 2 sides.
If any of you guys have not tried the 128 KB card, then I think it is worth trying. In Pune, the local Idea, Vodafone and Airtel centres did not know they had a 128 KB card. It took several visits and talking to several different personnel before one of the Airtel employee confirmed the availability of the card and and even then the other employee who keeps the cards could not recognise the difference.
Having spent a small fortune on the phone, it is frustrating when the phone is not working as advertised. And this has nothing to do with the phone being used before the official launch.
All the best guys and I hope the above suggestion of the 128 KB card works for you.