It's kind of funny, since if you did a search for my name, you would find me under Apple Haters. I have never liked Apple, as a company, but decided to buy the 4S because of experience with my wife's 3GS, and the iPhone 4 I used for a month (long story). It is simply head and shoulders above anything else in the market. I very carefully researched, for 6 months, the various smartphones that had the features I wanted, and it came down to the 4S or the Galaxy S II. The 4S won out because Android phones often don't get updates to their OS, and I had used a Windows phone for 2 years with NO updates. Compared with that, Apple's updates are fantastic.
I am not anti-consumer, but I see little benefit in attacking a company you want to help you. Warranties are pretty much local things, so what applies here may not apply where you are. My 30 day free return point ended 2 days ago, and I never once considered returning it.
I'm sorry some people have battery issues, and I'm sorry some people expect too much of the phone. I anticipated that the phone would use more battery power than the 4, but after turning off the things I didn't want, or need, and installing 5.01, I have very good battery life. At some point, I am pretty sure that Apple will announce what they have found relative to battery issues, and I expect those to be multiple causes. I hope they can be corrected via software, but who knows. They WON'T be corrected by legal action, but by talented technologists.