Just to update:
Late last night, I implemented a full reset to factory specs. I imported no data, account settings, apps, etc. All services were turned off with the exception of WiFi. I also pretty immediately added the System Activity Monitor app and left the phone - starting at 96% capacity - on all night. I last checked at 11:41 p.m. at 93% and first checked in the morning at 88%. It showed 41 minutes of usage (which was higher than actual).
A loss of 5% points over that time period was an amazing improvement.
Building off that, I opted to enable my Exchange account at 8:54 AM with 83% battery capacity.
The next 5 hours were spent nearly all in standby, excluding two calls for a total of 7 minutes. During that time I dropped 9% to 74%. By comparison, I've been had 30-45 minute periods exclusively in standby with that level of loss before the wipe and restore.
Given those results, I enabled contacts on the Exchange account. At 4:39, I had dropped to 69% - 5% in 2:40, roughly. Again, a significant improvement, at which time, I enabled the Exchange calendar.
In the hour, 20 minutes since then, I dropped 1% (though I'm likely not receiving any calendar invitations or notices given the day of the week) to 68%.
These are amazing results - ones that I did not think possible 24 hours ago.
Usage 2 Hours, 3 Minutes
Standby 20 Hours, 42 Minutes
Battery at 65% capacity
I'm not suggesting that this solution will work for every one. I'm not suggesting that it will hold for me.
However, doing a full reset sure seems to have paid some immediate results.