i start to think i have a good battery overall inside my 4S, seeing some cases over here, i am in the group of people that the slight usage drain like crazy group, i still didnt updated to 5.0.1 because we cant go back and still didnt see any reports of good improvments so far. still i made a test this is the 7 full cycle i made since i bought the phone, i have everything off, except celular data and imessage, because if i turn it off i wont receive any text messages, everything else-BT,icloud,siri, location, push, only 1 email account, notifications, weather, calendar,wifi, everything OFF.
charged at night from 0% to 100% around 7hours and removed from the charger as 9 A.M.
received 4 text messages
1 call of 2/3minutes
here is a print of when i noticed the drop to 99%

quite good in fact 5hours of standby to loose the first % is great
now the when i took this picture turned on wifi to email it, it dropped to 98% just 2 minutes later
just took another showing the drop to 98% and emailed it also

then i went into settings again to see what settings i had off so i can post here dropped to 97%
everything i do drops % every single time
and it will continue droping and now more easly then the first %.
still i think i cant really complain watching some cases here of intense drainage, but this phone is really hungry for juice... wish i could predict this before selling my iphone4, all i can do i not to recomend this to anyone that asks me about the 4s.
this might show if your battery is good or bad, turn off everything and charge it to 100%, if the mantains 100% for some standby hours it should be ok, the crazy usage drain is just the problem of the 4s in general and there is nothing we can do, it will only get worse in time.
just as i already said, imagine the battery of the 4s whit 1 year and 1000 charges on it, one 15min call will drop 40% hehehe My God.