Currently Being ModeratedOct 17, 2011 11:20 AM (in response to Themacguyver)
I am having the exact same problem with my Klipsch wired headset with AT&T. I switch to the Apple wired headset which did not fix the problem. I did not have this issue using the same headset with my 3Gs last week.
Currently Being ModeratedOct 17, 2011 12:12 PM (in response to c1717c)
I have been back to Apple and have switched the handset and headset for new ones and still am having the same problem. I have contacted my wireless provider to look further into this matter.
Currently Being ModeratedOct 17, 2011 1:00 PM (in response to Themacguyver)
Has anyone found a resolution to this issue yet? I'm experiencing the same exact problem. It doesn't happen right away, only if you've been on the phone for about 15 minutes.
Currently Being ModeratedOct 17, 2011 1:35 PM (in response to rnguyen)
The longest time it has taken for me so far is about 12 mins before it kicked in! The average time is between 1min to 6 mins for me. Im going to try and describe the sound as best as possible. When it happens the volume on the headset suddenly increases, as well as the white nose (snow) in the back ground increases to the point it pretty much over takes the conversation. The other person experiences quite alot of delay in the echo, about 2 seconds and we are no longer able to communicate with one another due to them hearing the echo. Unplugging the headset solves the problem, but will only come back once re-plugged in. Also I have noticed that my data from 3g usually drops to Edge or nil and my signal strength becomes very weak.
I would like to hear any more detailed feedback from any of you that you might have. ie carrier and phone type?
Currently Being ModeratedOct 17, 2011 3:38 PM (in response to Themacguyver)
Same thing happens to me. Very annoying. But, the echo is on the other side of the conversation. What I hear is the person sounds like they are all of a sudden really far away, but the volume of the voice increases and it's scratchy. At the same time this happens, the person on the other side of the call says there is all of a sudden an echo. I haven't tried unplugging the headset yet, because I pretty much always use the headset and don't want to give that up. I just hang up and call the person back. SOOOOOOO annoying!!!! I'm on AT&T 32 GB black iPhone 4S.
Currently Being ModeratedOct 17, 2011 3:48 PM (in response to Themacguyver)
My wife and I are experiecing the same issue. We just got our new iPhone 4S units (both 16GB), and this happened to us several times while we were speaking with each other today. I can't tell which one of us has the phone / headset that's causing the problem. She hears an echo on her headset, and I hear loud static. We're both using the Apple's included earbud / mic units. From the sound of things, which one of us has the problematic device / headset combo? Is the person who hears the echo or the person who hears the static?
Currently Being ModeratedOct 17, 2011 7:21 PM (in response to samchr)
I have the 4s 64 gb model and I'm on the AT&T network. The problem I'm experiencing is identical to what is described in the above thread. After being on a call for 10-15 minutes, the echo and static starts. The first three times it happened, I was dialed into a conference call for work so we all thought it was a conference line issue and all re-dialed in and it fixed it. Today, I was on a call with a friend and after 10 minutes, the echo and static came on. That made me realize my phone was the issue. So I hung up and called her back and the echo went away. I then researched online and found that this issue also happened to older iphone models. One of the suggestion that I found was when you are on a call using the earphones and the echo starts, put the call on speaker for 2 secs and take it off of speaker. I did this and the echo went away. This has worked every time to fix the echo issue. This sounds like an iphone equipment issue and not a carrier issue; I'm making a visit to the Apple store soon...
Currently Being ModeratedOct 18, 2011 3:01 AM (in response to rnguyen)
Ditto. New iPhone 4S with apple earbud headset. Only seems to happen with the headset. Static on my end, screech then echo on the other end after about 15 minutes of speaking. If I unplug the headset the problem seems to go away. Problem occurs with multiple apple headsets, so I imagine it's a handset / phone issue.
I'm going to wait until the next shipment of iPhone 4Ss is in until I take my phone into the Apple store.
Currently Being ModeratedOct 18, 2011 7:50 AM (in response to Themacguyver)
I'm having the same issue, but it doesn't matter whether I use the headset or not. 32GB / AT&T
Currently Being ModeratedOct 18, 2011 9:24 AM (in response to Themacguyver)
My sister and I are having the same problem you all are encountering. We have the new iPhone 4S 64GB and are with Rogers. We actually went to Apple store yesterday and got new phones, however we still have the problem. We don't know what to think, it would make sense that it is a hardware issue, however it seems to be a limited problem (in that there isn't a massive reporting on the issue, lots of message boards talking about it etc.). We wonder if it is carrier related, somehow... we just don't know.
My sister restored her phone to factory settings and used it and still had the problem. We've tried restoring, resetting the network, nothing works (other than unplugging the hands-free set). It seems there was the same issue with the iPhone 4 when it came out. There are some older threads on this, but I don't know what the final resolution was to the problem. The postings on it seemed to stop, so maybe it cleared up? No idea.
For samchr, the problem presents as the other person hearing an echo. So, if you are speaking with your wife and she hears the echo, then it is your phone, and vice versa. As my sister and I speak to each other on our new iPhones we've worked it out. Another way to check is to unplug the hands-free set and see if the problem goes away. Which ever one of you clears up the problem by unplugging the hands-free, that's the phone that is causing the issue.
The problem is sporadic, it makes it harder to diagnose. I was out walking and had a fairly long phone conversation (12 minutes) with no issues. On the phone with my sister yesterday, it happened about 8-9 minutes into the phone call (I believe, I didn't check). Today I was speaking with my sister for just a short time, and the problem happened, but on her end this time.
It's a real puzzle. If anyone finds out anything on this, PLEASE post the solution for us on this board!
Currently Being ModeratedOct 18, 2011 9:38 AM (in response to Themacguyver)
Ok for me I have found as a temporary fix that pressing the speaker phone button and then taking it off again corrects the problem. I have experienced it coming back again on the same call, but just press the speaker button again then off solves it. Let's hope there will be a permanent fix from apple in a software update.
Currently Being ModeratedOct 18, 2011 11:10 AM (in response to Themacguyver)
Yes, I can confirm that that solution works, thanks Themacguyver! It's a good short term solution anyway.
My sister (ms from toronto, see post above) and I are both scheduled to have our iPhone 4S's replaced again (so third iPhone 4S for both of us). Apple tech support asked us to confirm that this issue happens with a clean phone (not a restore), and it does. Waiting to hear back from the Apple store that they will have replacement devices available to swap out for us at our appts. on Thursday morning.
Currently Being ModeratedOct 18, 2011 11:19 AM (in response to Themacguyver)
Yes, as a short term solution doing the speaker trick works okay. Obviously it is not feasible long term.
As my sister (has2289) wrote above you may be asked to confirm the issue with a clean phone. I did a test with clean phone, called a land line and the problem occurred almost immediately (within about 1 minute). I did the speaker trick and the problem then reoccurred within less than 30 seconds!!! It seems the problem is even more evident on a clean phone. My sister and I spoke, while she had her 'clean' phone, and the problem happened three times within the phone call (I don't know how quickly the first occurrence took place, didn't look, but it was fairly soon into the phone call, maybe 5-7 minutes).
Hopefully new phones/completely replaced, will solve the issue. Let's all keep each other posted on what works/what we discover.
Currently Being ModeratedOct 18, 2011 12:50 PM (in response to Themacguyver)
I'm on my second O2 UK device already and I've still got the echo!