What do I need to import VHS tapes to Final Cut Pro X?

Sorry if this is the 1000th time that this has been asked, but I'm new to the world of capturing video from old VHS tapes. I have a great (well, it was great way back when...) JVS S-VHS player recorder. I had tried using Roxio's VHS-to-DVD with their little dangle thing which converts the audio R/L and composite and/or Svideo cables to USB, then into the Mac. Without boring you with details, I've given up on Roxio's program - it's way too buggy.


So, since I own Final Cut Pro X and I had intended on editing the results of my import with FCPX anyway, I thought "hey, why not just import it with FCPX and skip Roxio?" Well, I'm clearly missing some components or something. Obviously, my VHS deck does NOT support firewire, so if that's a prerequisite, then I'm stuck for now.


I'd like to hear from the crowd on what the minimum hardware / software requirements are to do this. I don't need perfect. I'm just trying to digitize the VHS movies on the computer to do some very minor edits and then burn a DVD.


Thoughts?

thanks

dc

iMac I7 (27"), Macbook Pro, MacMini, Mac OS X (10.6.3)

Posted on Dec 5, 2011 11:31 PM

Reply
4 replies

Sep 20, 2013 3:54 PM in response to DennisCo

How much do you care about what's on the VHS tapes? If it's not all that important, then a cheap composite video to USB converter will do. Capture software will probably come with hardware. There was an adapter that accompanied the EyeTV Hybrid receiver (don't know if that's still the case) so I no longer need the adapter and still have the TV receiver ( 😉 ). Roxio sells a converter rig. Both Elgato (EyeTV) and Roxio have software for recording as part of the package. [PS, neither of these options yielded adequate results... for me.]


If what you're trying to preserve is worth a small investment, then you should consider getting a higher grade converter like those sold by Canopus (or "Green Valley" whichever they're deciding to call themselves lately) — the ADVC-55 is an adequate starting point depending on your budget for the project. The ADVC-55 and better converters are Firewire and deliver timecode (you might need the power adapter if you only have FW800 connections). They can be used directly with FCPX to ingest the video. Any software that will record from Firewire will do, and I *believe* that includes Quicktime Player (X - but I'd recommend QT7Pro instead.)


The reason why the Canopus (and other similar) converters are superior is that they have the ability to amplify the signals (that might be somewhat worn) and they have firmware to help stabilize the incoming video signal. Where you might get "flipping" or tracking errors in the USB devices, the higher end converters are able to minimize those problems (I said *minimize*... some VHS video is unrecoverable, no matter what.)


Ideally, you should play the tapes on the same machine that recorded them, provided the player is still in excellent functional condition. Clean the heads before recovery ("dry" tape should be acceptable). I also recommend that you fast forward and rewind each tape at least a couple of times, end to end, each (helps re-align the tape in the cartridge.) If you find a lot of tracking problems, look into a new vhs deck with as much resolution as you can find. By that, I mean most inexpensive players available at the local electronics or tv stores deliver about 280 lines of vertical resolution (they're cheap for a reason!) Panasonic used to have sets that delivered 520 lines (it will probably be a miracle if you can find one with that much resolution.) If you can find one with 400 or more lines, it's a good find.


Recover everything then sell the vhs equipment on ebay (if you had to buy something new.... or not.)


— Don't look back 😀

Dec 6, 2011 12:09 AM in response to DennisCo

Well, “Easy VHS to DVD for Mac” captures the video in MPEG-2 format,

which can be burned directly to DVD...


Those files have to be converted before importing them into FCP X...

MPEG Streamclip with the MPEG-2 Playback Component can do this...


Another consumer product is “Elgato Video Capture for Mac”...

This one can capture directly to H.264 or MPEG-4... No conversion needed for FCP X...


Otherwise, you might like and check out some of the “Canopus” grass valley products.

ADVC 55 / 110 / 300. One of those should do the job nicely...

http://www.grassvalley.com/products


Regards

Nolan

Sep 19, 2013 3:22 PM in response to DennisCo

Have you tried capturing the footage through QuickTime X? If not, try this:

Open QuickTime Player.

Select File>New Movie Recording.

The resulting window will probably display your iSight camera. Click the down arrow to the right of the record button, and you should be able to select the source(s), quality, and destination of the captured file.


In my experience, that method will capture through dropped frames.


Good luck!

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

What do I need to import VHS tapes to Final Cut Pro X?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.