Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

how many GB can you have as a boot drive on Macbook Pro os x lion

hi everyone, i'm gonna connect a 3 tb internal drive (3.5 inch) to my Macbook Pro 15 inch 2011 via sata data extension, and a external power source connected to the hdd. I'm still a high school student, so i barely take it out of my desk, so i want to tweak ita little, because desktop hdd are faster, and i don't want to waste 300< just for a ssd with barely storage. i'm planning to make 1 tb os x lion, 1 tb boot camp, and 1 tb time machine. if you want the links to what I bought ask me, btw which 3 tb is better wd, toshiba, etc?

MacBook Pro, Mac OS X (10.7.2), Macbook Pro 15 inch (Late 2011)

Posted on Dec 14, 2011 7:03 PM

Reply
20 replies

Dec 14, 2011 8:43 PM in response to ericksol96

Your idea of backing up your boot volume via Time Machine to another partition on the same disk is foolhardy. If the drive fails, as all drives do sooner or later, everything will be gone including the backup. You might as well not back up at all as leave yourself vulnerable to that disaster. Always use a separate disk for backup. If you do, you will also sidestep the knotty problem of creating a boot camp partition on a multi-partitioned drive, which Boot Camp Assistant really doesn't want to do.

Dec 15, 2011 3:08 AM in response to ericksol96

If you think you need 1.5TB for OSX, you should have a 3TB drive for Time Machine. But I suspect you don't really need 1.5 TB for either OSX or Windows, and could make do just fine with a pair of 1TB or 2TB drives, one internal and the other external for a TM backup of OSX. I don't see any merit in the idea of connecting a bare 3.5" drive externally to the hard drive bay in a MBP.

Dec 15, 2011 3:42 AM in response to ericksol96

Having 1TB of free space available isn't going to make Windoze any faster than having 500 GB available. Either is far more than enough. And the hassles you're likely to encounter using an externally-powered drive for your OS while connecting it to a SATA cable that's designed to power a drive make the whole project enough of a gamble to be just silly.

Dec 15, 2011 4:02 AM in response to ericksol96

Hi


This really becomes down to an old saying: "You can have a good system or a cheap system". Not both at the same time.


As eww already stated you probably do not need 1,5GB for OS X or even WIN7 system. And the speed of an operating system comes down not when the partition has nearly filled, but it is rather related to the physical drive utilization. But OS X and WIN7 are both quite good handeling the hardware even when it's not that top-noch.


If you are into storage, buy a separate external storage device (for about $250 per 2TB) and attach it via FireWire - http://store.westerndigital.com/store/wdus/en_US/DisplayProductDetailsPage/produ ctID.106590800


And have a 1TB harddrive for operating systems giving both the MAC and WIN about 500GB of diskspace. That would set you back for about $100 or less.


So for a total of 3TB of storage you would then have been spent around $350 and you have a system that can deliver both speed and reliability.


Keep in mind that when you have the timemachine backup on the same physical drive as the stuff you are backing up, it does not only make the backup unnessecary but it will also make the usage of the computer very slow during the backup since the backup proccess reads and writes to the same physical drive.


I understand your technical curiosity and its not in anyway wrong to poke around (as I have done so as-well) but just understand that when you create this hazard platform combining original and "backup" data on the same drive you should really consider what information you store on that system. Just something to think about.

how many GB can you have as a boot drive on Macbook Pro os x lion

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.