ATI RADEON 5770 in Mac Pro 2009 High PCI Fan Noise!

I installed last November a brand new ATI Radeon 5770 in my Mac Pro 4.1 Early 2009 Dual 2.26 and everything was great, except for the PCI fan which was running high for a few minutes, around 2000RPM, then went down to 800RPM, now for over 1 week the PCI fan won't go below 1500RPM and drives me insane. No other software was installed or mod made. It runs on OS X Lion 10.7.2

Any ideas or a fix for this issue?

This is NOT normal for a retail card sold by Apple that should be compatible with all Mac Pros.

Posted on Jan 15, 2012 6:18 AM

Reply
13 replies

Jan 15, 2012 9:35 AM in response to Flocarino

At startup, Hardware sets the fans to maximum. As the software reads the temperatures of various components, the fan speeds may be adjusted downward if appropriate. A software crash will stop resetting the fan speed, so the Hardware will revert fan speed to maximum to avoid a meltdown.


In a running system, if temperature measurements remain high, fan speed will not be adjusted downward. I expect this is your problem. There are two common causes:


1) Dust buildup inside your Mac in general and in the graphics card fan in particular. this increases heat buildup and makes the fans run faster.


The approved method for removing dust involves Blowing the dust out of your Mac and into the air. Do this on the white carpet in the Living Room, and you are going to be sleeping in the doghouse for quite a while. Regular plastic vacuum cleaner wands and tools generate huge electronics-killing static charges, and should not be used inside your Mac.


2) Failure of any of the internal sensors: on the graphics card, a memory module, a processor, or in the PCIe slot area. Apple Hardware Test can tell you whether a sensor has failed.

Jan 15, 2012 9:53 AM in response to Grant Bennet-Alder

The Mac is sparkling clean inside, I always use a duster and I even clean the heatsinks of the CPUs and applied new thermal paste on the CPUs. The ONLY trick to get the RPM run at 800RPM is to open OpenGL Extensions Viewer, run a test for approx. 20 seconds, then quit the program. The PCI fan will immediately go down from 2000RPM to 800RPM, this is definitely software related. This is not normal and I wonder if I upgrade to a ATI 5870, I won't have the same problem.

I'm sure Apple is aware of this glitch.

Jan 15, 2012 10:19 AM in response to Flocarino

I'm sure Apple is aware of this glitch.

I don't think so.


Yours is the first report of this problem I have seen. If there were a pervasive problem your post would be mobbed by a hundred or more "Me too!" posters.


I expect this is not a general problem, but a problem with your specific card or software set-up. Maybe you should show the guys at the genius bar.

Jan 15, 2012 11:41 AM in response to Flocarino

Sorry toe hear about the unexpected behavior of your display card fan. The worst thing about a noisy tower is that all you want to do with it is shut it off.


Have you run the Apple Hardware Test disc?


Also, how do the fans behave if you do a Safe Boot? Or, how about if you log in under a new user account? Or, if you boot with the system restore disc? As part of your troubleshooting steps, try to see if theses different boot options duplicate the fan issue or not. As I am sure that you are aware, this will eventual rule out either hardware or software as the issue.




-Warren

Jan 15, 2012 2:53 PM in response to Flocarino

No change, 1 restart later the PCI Fan went up again so I dismantled the whole thing. Removed everything from the case, even checked the voltage of the PRAM battery, reassembled everything and still the same.

I reinstalled SMC Fan control and I open and close OpenGL Extensions Viewer application so the PCI fan drops down to 800RPM as usual....honest to God, this is the worst MAC I ever had and Apple sells graphic cards with software glitches.😠

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

ATI RADEON 5770 in Mac Pro 2009 High PCI Fan Noise!

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.