5 Replies Latest reply: Nov 30, 2013 4:45 PM by spikesagal
HawaiianHippie Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

Aloha all!

 

Extensive internet searching has lead me to believe that Garageband cannot take a single stereo track and split it into 2 mono tracks.  Every solution to "how do I do this" involves exporting the track to another piece of software, performing the separation there, then re-importing the new files into GB.

 

My question is to the Apple desighers:  Why doesn't Garageband have such a simple, and commonly-needed, ability? 

 

People have been asking this question since iLife '04, if not before.  It's something that genuinely criples Garageband as an audio production tool.  I work with a college radio station, and we use Garageband for most of our audio production, mainly because it's easy enough for non-techie people to understand.  However, when often send people out to do interviews armed with digital recorders, and get back stereo files with one mic on the left channel and the other on the right.  Havng to wash those files through something else before using them in grageband really, really negates the whole "keep it simple" premise we try to operate under.

 

So, please, listen to the feedback you've been getting since day 1.  

  • HangTime Level 9 Level 9 (50,195 points)

    HawaiianHippie wrote:

     

    Garageband cannot take a single stereo track and split it into 2 mono tracks.

     

    correct, but there is a workaround if you use iTunes as well:

     

    http://www.bulletsandbones.com/GB/GBFAQ.html#stereotomono

    (Let the page FULLY load. The link to your answer is at the top of your screen)

     

     

    HawaiianHippie wrote:

     

    So, please, listen to the feedback you've been getting since day 1.  

     

    this is a user to user support forum with no official Apple presense, you need to get your message to them:

     

    http://www.bulletsandbones.com/GB/GBFAQ.html#sendfeedback

    (Let the page FULLY load. The link to your answer is at the top of your screen)

  • guitarnut75 Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    Um, just a thought (and I know this thread is a bit old) but couldn't you just pan the stereo track over to one side in GB, then dupe the track and pan it all the other way... I just tried it and it sounds like you are getting just one side of the stereo image each time....

  • HawaiianHippie Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    Aloha guitarnut, and thaks for taking the time to contribute to my aged thread!

     

    yes, you can do what you are describing, but what you end up with is not two mono tracks, just two stereo tracks, each missing half of the recording.

     

    The distinction is that what I want is to have both voices on both channels.  As recorded, Bob is on the left channel and Denise is on the right.  I want both Bob and Denise to be on both channels after editing.

  • aslam Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    HawaiianHippie,

     

    I understand exactly what you are trying to do and I need to accomplish a very similar task.

     

    It has been more than a year since your original post so I thought I would ask if you come up with any better way to accomplish this inside GarageBand without having to do the "export to iTunes" method that HangTime suggested? What about outside of GarageBand; have you found another app that will help you do this?

     

    To give you more context, I am working with choral learning tracks that are used by choir singers to help them learn their parts. We use a series of "part dominant" tracks for this purpose. A part dominant track has an indvidual part playing in the left side and all the other parts playing on the right side. For example, if I am learning the Bass part I get a track that has the Bass part in the left side and then all the other parts (Sopranno, Alto, Tenor) on the right side. What I want to accomplish is one of to outcomes:

     

    Good: create a mono "part missing" track which would involve talking the right side of my part dominant track (the side that contains all the voices except for my Bass part) and then make a new mono track from that. This will allow me to practice singing with a track that contains all the parts EXCEPT for mine and has them coming out of both ears.

     

    Better: Use each of the isolated part dominant tracks to create a stereo part missing track. This is where I would take all of the left side of the part dominant tracks (the side that has only one part) and then create a stereo mix of all the parts EXCEPT for my part. The reason that I want to do this as a mix is because then I can mix the tracks into a balance that matches the blend that we are looking for as a choir and/or match how loud the other voices will sound to me when I am standing amongst my peers singing to simulate real world.

     

    Any ideas on how I can accomplish this?

     

    Thanks,

    Aslam

  • spikesagal Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    I have a solution!

     

    It works in GarageBand 10, using the Join Regions feature. I haven't tried it in earlier versions, but chances are it might work there as well. Here's what you need to do:

     

    1) Create a "Left Channel" track. Import or record your stereo audio into it. If recording, make sure you're using the stereo recording mode. Pan this track all the way to the left.

     

    2) Create a "Right Channel" track. Copy and paste the region from "Left Channel" into it. Pan this track all the way to the right.

     

    3) Create a piece of blank audio. You can do this by recording from the line input when nothing's plugged into it. It doesn't matter how long it is, as long as you are able to select the region. Let's name this track "Blank Audio 1". Make sure it's somewhere below the "Left Channel" track.

     

    4) You're going to need this for both channels, so create a track called "Blank Audio 2", then copy and paste the region from "Blank Audio 1" into it. Make sure that it's somewhere below the "Right Channel" track.

     

    5) Here's where the magic begins. Shift-select the audio regions from "Left Channel" and "Blank Audio 1". On the application menu lick Edit -> Join Regions. Select "Mono". You now have a separate left channel on a mono track.

     

    6) Shift-select the audio regions from "Right Channel" and "Blank Audio 2". Click Edit -> Join Regions. Select "Mono". You now have a separate right channel on a mono track. Hooray!

     

    Note that since your left channel is panned all the way to the left, and your right channel is panned all the way to the right, the mix will sound exactly the same as the original. You can now mix the stereo pan by controlling the volume sliders of the two mono tracks. You can also mix one channel into the other, or flip the channels, by changing the panning controls of the two mono tracks!

     

    HTH